A Mean-spirited Letter on Parental Choice

A letter to the editor in today’s Post shows the ugly, mean-spirited attitude of some opponents of parental choice:
 

Regarding “School tax credits die in state House” (March 8): Missouri House Speaker Rod Jetton, R-Marble Hill, never ceases to amaze me. His support of a Missouri House bill to give tax credits to send urban kids to private schools is a slap in the face to the rural school districts he is supposed to represent. The article said that this bill could cost the state up to $40 million in tax credits.

As House speaker, it is a testament to his poor leadership that 35 Republican representatives voted against the bill. Thank goodness the bill was defeated. I live in Mr. Jetton’s district. The only good thing about that is that he is term-limited and cannot serve another term as a state representative. Maybe next time around we can get a representative who cares more about the needs of rural schools than making a career in politics.

There are several problems with this argument. First, the state of Missouri spends about $5 billion per year on K-12 education each year, so the $40 million price tag amounts to less than one percent of the state budget. I wonder if Mr. Page writes letters to the editor every time the legislature spends $40 million in an effort to help inner-city kids.

Second, if the author’s point is that rural taxpayers shouldn’t be forced to subsidize the education of inner-city kids, he’s long since lost that battle. The state already pays significantly more per-pupil to the Saint Louis and Kansas City school districts than they do elsewhere in the state. Saint Louis receives $5500 per pupil from the state, compared with only $4200 per pupil for the author’s hometown of Fredericktown.

Most importantly, the author fails to consider the fact that the cost to the state of his program would be far less than $40 million. It’s true that the HB808 would issue up to $40 million in tax credits. However, many of the scholarships distributed as part of the tax credit program would go to kids who otherwise would have gone to public schools. Some (or depending on the details, potentially all) of the costs of the tax credit program would be offset by savings due to the fact that the state had to educate fewer kids through the public schools. So the true cost of the tax credit program would be substantially less than $40 million.

If the author is truly worried about threats to his pocketbook, he should be writing letters to the editor about the so-called adequacy lawsuit now wending its way through the court system. That could mandate billions of dollars in additional spending. And worst of all, it would require that all of the money be given to the same public schools that have squandered so many millions already. If there’s one thing that’s worse than being forced to pay for the education of other peoples’ kids, it’s being forced to pay for an ineffective effort to educate other peoples’ kids.

We Don’t Need More Clinics in Schools

Do health clinics belong in public schools? The St. Louis Post-Dispatch reports that the idea hasn’t taken hold in Missouri as it has in Illinois:

The Metro East area has two of these high school clinics, the one in East St. Louis and another in Cahokia.

In contrast, the whole state of Missouri has just three, according to the National Assembly on School-Based Health Care, a nonprofit group in Washington.

Providing preventative health care to poor children is imperative, but attaching the service to public schools is the wrong way to go. The existing system of public schools excacerbates disparities in education, because the children with the fewest choices are stuck in the worst schools. If a child’s health care provider also depends on his address, we’ll have greater health care injustice.

My libertarian guilty pleasure is government funding for the arts…

My esteemed colleague, Sarah Brodsky, has recently posted on government funding for the arts.  The traditional free-market view of this is general opposition, although for reasons of taxes and budgets rather than taste or attitudes. Sarah gently critiques Gov. Blunt for his comments supporting arts funding and, in particular, his statement that arts funding helps lead to economic development. Sarah quotes Tyler Cowen on the issue of economic development studies, but I find Mr. Cowen’s remarks to be a very accurate smackdown of Chamber of Commerce-type economic development studies themselves, not funding for the arts in general. We here in St. Louis are privileged to have the local RCGA, which is a gigantic conflict of interest in its dual role as economic forecaster and cheerleader for the region.  Does anyone actually believe anything in these studies?

The next point Sarah references in her post is about the difficulties of remaining as a small-business in a newly popular area. I have two solutions for the issue of independent businesses being forced out by higher rents and taxes in fashionable area. Solution # 1: Lower the tax rate. Really, most downtown areas have special taxing districts (both downtown St. Louis and Clayton have them). If the rents and property values rise quickly (we should be so lucky in downtown St. Louis) it is easy enough to lower the special taxing district rate to make it easier for the smaller or merely less-hip businesses to remain. Solution # 2: If that is the way it is, than so be it.

I don’t mean to sound cruel, but I LOVE GENTRIFICATION! If a business can no longer make it because a new cultural center moves into the area and brings with it all the hipness (and expensiveness) you can handle, well, those are the breaks, independent bookstore-dude. I should be very clear here that I am not encouraging eminent domain to forcibly remove Mr. independent bookstore and Ms. clothing resale shop. In fact, I like both of them very much, but change and progress are not meant to be easy, and if an art center comes to your neighborhood and the free market decides other businesses compliment it more, than so be it.

But back to government funding of arts. I like it local, low level and without strings. I don’t think it should be a large amount of money and certainly not a gravy-train for artists, but oftentimes the results are well worth the investment. “Man on a Horse” right here in Clayton, for example.

Whose road is being traveled?

St. Louis County has used a carrot and stick approach to dealing with local municipalities regarding the necessary traffic changes during the upcoming Highway 40 reconstruction projest.  Apparently, the carrot has been successful.  Agreements have been reached with Ladue, Frontenac and Town and Country for the County to take over Clayton and Ladue Roads during the project for the purpose of speeding up traffis so they may be better used by commuters.  Of course, the fact that St. Louis County has the legal right to take over all the roads at any point, and was willing to do just that, made the carrot much more appealing to the cities.  Basically, we are now going to have traffic lights at some well-known intersections which before had "Stop" signs intentionally placed to prevent heavy commuter traffic.  These intersections, off the top of my head, will include Price and Clayton, Price and Ladue, McKnight and Litzsinger, Clayton and Lay, and Warson and Ladue.  I don’t mind that the "Stop" signs are there to prevent heavy traffic before, and I have no problem with their return after construction, but I commend St. Louis County for making certain these imperative changes will go ahead quickly. 

Kids Don’t Have a Few More Years

Brian Lewis’s column on HB808 illustrates just how much work advocates of parental choice still have to do in educating Missourians about how choice works and why it’s important. Lewis says that “Taking kids out of bad schools and putting them in ones that aren’t high-performing systems doesn’t solve any problems” and that “You’ve got to fix the system first.”

There are a couple of problems with this. In the first place, taking kid a out of a bad school and putting her into a better schools does solve a problem: it gives that child a better education. It’s downright bizarre that Lewis doesn’t even acknowledge this. Even if all parental choice did was help a few kids get into better schools, that would seem like a major argument in favor. Helping some kids is better than helping no kids.

But in fact, the argument for choice is a lot stronger than that. Because choice is a way to “fix the system.” The fundamental problem with “the system” is that public schools are monopolies, with no accountability to the vast majority of parents who aren’t wealthy enough to take their children elsewhere. As anyone who has studied economics will tell you, monopolies routinely deliver an inferior product at high prices.

Lewis says that “to really turn things around would take a few years.” What he doesn’t point out is that pundits have been saying this for decades. Over and over again, the public school bureaucracy has insisted that if we just give them more money and “a few years,” they’ll turn things around. Over and over again, we’ve poured more money into urban schools, only to see things continue to get worse. “We just need more money and more time” might have been believable in the 1980s or the 1990s, but in 2007, it doesn’t pass the straight face test.

Most importantly, the kids who are in failing schools today don’t have “a few years” to spare. Every year we wait for the public schools to fix themselves is a year that tens of thousands of kids miss out on the opportunity to get a great education. Poor kids need help now, in 2007. Parental choice is one of the few reforms that promise to bring them help immediately, not at the end of yet another 5-year plan.

Closing the Golden Door

Missouri legislators are trying to make it even harder for illegal immigrants to get an education or earn a living. State Sen Chris Koster explains why:

"At various points in our country’s history we have become addicted to cheap, illegal labor. We are again becoming addicted to cheap, illegal labor,” Koster said. “Unless we remove the needle of addiction from our arm in the very near future, we will not be able to ever get it out.”

First of all, if you allow immigrants to go to school, their labor won’t be cheap any more. Problem solved. Second, hiring unskilled immigrants isn’t a harmful addiction, it’s a way to help people who have few other opportunities.

If this country hadn’t been more open to immigration in the past, I’d probably be working for a Russian or Turkish free-market think tank right now. And I doubt that "Koster" is a Native-American family name either.

School Choice for the Lucky

Kids who are born into wealthy families get to attend whichever schools are best for them. Kids who are born into poverty aren’t so fortunate. As Clint Bolick writes in the Wall Street Journal:

There’s something about our nation’s capital that converts many leading Democrats to school choice. Perhaps it’s the glimpse that Washington, D.C. affords into inner-city public schools.

But in most cases this appreciation of school choice extends only to their own children — and not to the millions of children in failing public schools.

We see the same hypocricy in Missouri. Although the 196 administrators employeed by the St. Louis public schools earn an average of over $75,000 a year, administrators and school board members oppose a tuition tax credits bill that would direct help to low-income children.

Bridge compromise?

Last week, I blogged about how I liked the Martin Luther King bridge expansion idea as a plan to improve transportation across the Mississippi.  It seems that County Executive Charlie Dooley has now given a cautious endorsement of that deal, provided the plan meets certain guarantees, all of which seem very reasonable.  This plan strikes me more each time I study it as a very sensible and, in context, affordable solution to the transportation needs of metro Saint Louis.  While I like the toll bridge idea too, as a Missouri taxpayer I like even more the idea of Illinois paying for almost all of it.  Plus, my own experiences with the MLK bridge lead me to beleive an expanded bridge could really serve the needs of our community. 

Now all we have to do is expand MetroLink to Madison and St. Charles Counties, paid for by local taxpyers only, and we will be in good shape.   

Free inquiry, not legislation, should insure intellectual diversity

A recent controversy has arisen over the state of intellectual diversity in Missouri’s colleges and universities. A proposed house bill would create measures to insure that these schools are doing enough to promote this kind of diversity. The controversy arose over an incident at Missouri State University involving a professor making political demands of a student. Proponents of the bill argue that our state universities have become strongholds of liberal ideology, and that many professors and administrators discriminate against students and one another on the bases of ideology or political orientation.

While requiring professors to leave their political affiliations at the door is vital to preserving academic integrity, requiring institutions to monitor the "intellectual diversity" of classrooms would only serve to obstruct the principles of free inquiry and expression upon which higher education is founded. The key to intellectual diversity in classrooms and institutions lies in permitting dissenting views to be heard, and treating those views on their academic merit. That does not mean requiring professors to fully air both sides of a controversial issue, nor does it mean permitting those professors to evaluate student performance based on their adherence to that professor’s beliefs. What it means is that professors and students should be allowed to freely challenge one another’s beliefs and assumptions on academic grounds with no recourse to grades or other performance evaluations. This will insure intellectual diversity in our universities, without undermining the concepts of free inquiry and expression that have made our Missouri schools great in the first place.

Support Us

The work of the Show-Me Institute would not be possible without the generous support of people who are inspired by the vision of liberty and free enterprise. We hope you will join our efforts and become a Show-Me Institute sponsor.

Donate
Man on Horse Charging