I was recently spending time with friends who were playing the popular video game Mortal Kombat. While watching, I became intrigued and wanted to play.
I eagerly grabbed a controller and began to play, with no tutorial or instruction. Soon, my fascination with the game decreased as I continued losing (badly), and I declared, “Wow, I am horrible at this.” However, I eventually stopped ramming my head against a wall and at the urging of my friends, agreed to complete a brief tutorial. It clicked. I returned to the game and I was then able to discover different intricacies on my own. I was better equipped and ready for self-discovery.
You will have to forgive my long analogy, but I believe it is relevant. Far too often in the education sector, phonics and science of reading instruction are treated as a draconian, fun-killing endeavor that makes students never want to touch a book again.
But what about people like me, as I was repeatedly failing at Mortal Kombat, and just about to give up altogether? Students need to be taught skills directly, even if it’s “not fun.” A period of structured instruction and deliberate practice is far better than an indefinite period of feeling like a failure and wanting to avoid something altogether (like I have with roller skating ever since middle school. One day I’ll let someone teach me!).
Some students may need only a tiny bit of instruction before discovering much on their own. We often describe these students as “naturals.” But generally, direct instruction is tremendously valuable.
Education researcher Chad Aldeman puts it like this:
Students often need a dose of direct instruction to gain knowledge about a topic before they can write about, analyze, compare, or think critically. They need a solid base of knowledge to exercise those skills, and some amount of carefully constructed direct instruction can often help them get there.
Reading is an exciting subject, and there is so much joy in discovery through reading. Yet those who have not been taught properly can let discouragement keep them from discovering. That’s why early literacy reform is imperative: We need more Missouri students to become confident, capable readers.
Literacy reform failed to pass last year, but my colleagues and I will continue to push for reforms based on our early literacy model policy during the upcoming legislative session. Hopefully, Missouri lawmakers will finally give our children the support they need.
