Part 1: Expanding School Choice Is A Choice

Missouri Senate Bill 125, which goes into effect on Aug. 28, will change Missouri’s state education policy. The law will allow the State Board of Education (SBOE) to intervene in unaccredited school districts more quickly and with greater authority. The SBOE can now take over an unaccredited district immediately instead of waiting two years. The SBOE can choose to leave the existing district board in control or appoint a temporary special administrative board (SAB). SB 125 could be good or bad news for school choice, depending on how SBOE leaders decide to use it.

Simply putting a SAB in charge is not a long-term solution. Failing schools are a result of systemic problems in the public school system. If new management does not change the fundamental structure, then districts are likely to lapse into their old ways once local boards regain control. In that case, SB 125 effectively shifts unnecessary power to the state, which could be bad news.

However, when a SAB takes over a district, it has the opportunity to make systemic changes. For example, the SAB in Saint Louis recently chose to diversify its portfolio of schools by forming a partnership with KIPP. Decisions like these that promote school choice are forward-thinking, lasting solutions. If the state uses its new authority to expand school choice, then SB 125 is good news.

Though there is hope that SB 125 could lead to better options for students, it overlooks an important issue. Too much time is spent focusing on district accreditation, when the spotlight ought to be on the individual school. More on this in my next post.

Opposing Tax Cuts, Supporting Bigger Government, And The Wisdom Of Milton Friedman

Few economists of the 20th Century had as wide and substantive an impact on the political discourse as Milton Friedman. The 1976 recipient of the Nobel Prize, Friedman not only was a student of free-market economics but one of its great communicators, evangelizing the values of the free market in books, on television, and even on blogs. Friedman was a quintessential happy warrior for the cause of economic freedom, remaining active in the movement late into his life and providing clear, principled advice on tax policy to young politicos throughout his later years.

Although I could cite a host of Friedman literature on the subject of taxes, I’d like to just highlight one interview he did in 2003, at the age of 90, with John Hawkins. Asked whether “the Bush tax cuts” were the “right thing” to do, Friedman replied that he was “in favor of cutting taxes under any circumstances and for any excuse, for any reason, whenever it’s possible.“

The reason I am is because I believe the big problem is not taxes, the big problem is spending. The question is, “How do you hold down government spending?” Government spending now amounts to close to 40% of national income not counting indirect spending through regulation and the like. If you include that, you get up to roughly half. The real danger we face is that number will creep up and up and up. The only effective way I think to hold it down, is to hold down the amount of income the government has. The way to do that is to cut taxes. [Emphasis mine.]

Creep, indeed. Ten years later in Missouri, supporters of Gov. Jay Nixon’s tax cut veto have delivered a parade of horribles about what will happen if the legislature overrides the governor’s veto and Missourians get tax relief. They claim (among other things) that the state will have to leave bills unpaid and cut education, its bond rating will decline, dogs and cats will live together… in short, mass hysteria. No, public education funding won’t be eviscerated by giving the People back their money, and as to the bonds, of course it wasn’t a tax cut that imperiled Missouri’s rating earlier this year. It was … the prospect of new government spending, specifically in the Medicaid program. That’s an inconvenient fact which, in all the bluster about credit ratings, veto/Obamacare supporters hope you forget.

That’s because it’s all interconnected. Missouri’s tax cut opponents don’t want taxes cut because less tax revenue would prevent them from maintaining and growing the size of state government — whether they say it explicitly or not. It was spending, not tax cutting, that imperiled our bond rating this winter. And if I might repeat Friedman’s words here, “The only effective way I think to hold [the government’s size] down, is to hold down the amount of income the government has. The way to do that is to cut taxes.”

Friedman was right. If you support smaller government, you support tax cuts. And in my view, if you support bigger government but don’t want to say so, you make excuses instead. I think Missourians are tired of excuses.

Shining A Light On A School Transfer Solution

The school transfer case has placed education at the center of attention in Saint Louis. Many are eagerly watching the events unfold as students begin school. As far as I know, there haven’t been many problems. Nevertheless, this issue has created numerous frustrations in the community. This has led many to start looking for solutions to the school transfer problem.

Today, the St. Louis Beacon published my op-ed that provides a potential fix — private school scholarships. There are some clear advantages to giving students access to private schools:

First, a scholarship program maximizes individual choice; it allows students and their parents to pick the school they want, whether public or private.

Second, in providing access to a greater number of schools, a scholarship program lessens the outsized impact on a few suburban schools, which attract unusually large numbers of transfer students.

Third, a scholarship program would eliminate the financial trauma that school districts like Normandy and Riverview Gardens now are feeling from having to pay tuition and transportation costs between $10,000 and $20,000 for each transferring student.

Creating a private school scholarship program certainly wouldn’t solve the problems overnight, but it would begin putting the system in place for improvement to occur.

James Shuls, Ph.D, on Redefining Public Education

The Show-Me Institute recognized this year’s Friedman Legacy for Freedom Day, 7/31/2013, with a policy breakfast in Springfield, Missouri, which featured James Shuls, Ph.D. The Springfield Libray Center hosted the event, and twenty-seven (27) guests attended. The program focused on school choice, with Shuls speaking about his work on education policy and how we should redefine public education. At 8 AM, Show-Me Institute Director Louis Griesemer gave brief remarks. He then introduced Missouri Rep. Eric Burlison (R-Dist. 133). Rep. Burlison talked about his efforts in the state legislature to support school choice reform before introducing Dr Shuls.

Dr. Shuls discussed perceptions of public education in the community. Shuls argues that the view of public education is often inaccurate, and should be results oriented instead of process oriented. Rather than thinking about public education as simply government schools that often fail to properly educate kids, it should be viewed as any institution that can adequately serve the public’s interest in an educated citizenry. The fact that an educational institution may be private does not change the fact that the students it teaches are members of the public. Shuls emphasized how the Show-Me Institute is working to change these perceptions in Missouri. Beyond events like these, the Show-Me institute works to inform the public via social media, the Show-Me Institute website, and local TV and radio.

alt

What’s Up Kansas City? Video From The Urban Summit

On Aug. 3, I had the great pleasure of participating in a panel discussion about education in Kansas City. The Urban Summit hosted the event. The panelists included Rev. Wallace Hartsfield, Missouri Rep. Gail McCann-Beatty (D-Dist. 43), Missouri Sen. KiKi Curls (D-Dist. 9), and Doug Thaman of the Missouri Charter Public School Association.

Thanks to What’s Up Kansas City, you can view my comments below.

Video: Redefining Public Education

I spoke on July 31 in Springfield, Mo., in honor of Friedman Legacy Day. The title of my talk was “Redefining Public Education.” The Show-Me Institute also released my essay with the same name, which you can read here. Video of the event is below. Enjoy.

Introduction from Show-Me Institute Director Louis Griesemer:

Remarks from Missouri Rep. Eric Burlison (R-Dist. 133):

The speech from yours truly:

More Like This. . .Please?

The Carter Carburetor building has sat dilapidated for numerous years and is a blight for the city of Saint Louis. Just a few decades ago, the Carter Carburetor Corporation was a major employer in the Saint Louis area. Today, the 4-story main building sits empty after Carter Building Inc. (CBI) donated the property to the Saint Louis Land Reutilization Authority (LRA). The LRA’s job is to return property to private use. Unfortunately, the agency has not always accomplished that.

Given the building’s current state, it is exciting that the LRA has found a positive future for the property. The owners of CBI donated the property to the LRA with the understanding that once the current environmental clean-up is complete, the land will be given to the Herbert Hoover Boys and Girls Club.

boys and girls club

The LRA is not responsible for the site’s clean-up, but it is responsible for what happens to the property after that. While the president of the Boys and Girls Club, Flint Fowler, said he looks forward to the Club’s expansion, some locals are wary of the property’s future. Loletta Zasaretii, a resident of the neighborhood, said she would rather see jobs created on the property instead of  “just another ball field.” Although many share Zasaretti’s desire for more jobs in North Saint Louis, the LRA is making the right decision because it is not holding onto the property.

The LRA may not be solving all of the neighborhood’s problems by handing the property over to the Herbert Hoover Boys and Girls Club, a non-profit, tax–exempt organization. But it is definitely moving in the right direction toward improving Saint Louis. Along with making the property more attractive and safer, the Boys and Girls Club — rather than the city — would be responsible for the land’s upkeep. Most importantly, the LRA deserves credit for getting the property off the city’s balance sheet and back into private ownership and productive use. Why can’t the LRA do this same thing with the thousands of other properties it owns?

No, The Volunteer Health Services Act Didn’t Offer ‘Blanket Immunity’ To Out-of-State Doctors

Just before the Fourth of July holiday, Missouri Gov. Jay Nixon vetoed the Volunteer Health Services Act. The legislation — which would have allowed out-of-state health professionals to more easily offer free care to needy Missourians — was criticized in Nixon’s veto message for creating “blanket immunity” for such doctors.

Just one problem with that claim: it’s not true. Don’t believe this lawyer? How about . . . the Missouri Association of Trial Attorneys?

Sharon Jones, deputy director of the Missouri Association of Trial Attorneys, which initially opposed the bill, said “even in times of emergency people need to be careful and they need to be responsible. If you harm someone, you should still be held responsible for the harm that you’ve caused.”

But the bill doesn’t actually grant blanket immunity. Trial lawyers stopped actively working against the legislation after language was added providing for civil penalties if health workers engage in “willful misconduct” or a “gross deviation from the ordinary standard of care,” Jones said. [Emphasis mine.]

What a disaster. Assuming the governor wrote his veto message, there is now a serious question about whether he read the bill before he killed it. Does he stand by his veto message? And the big question now with the upcoming veto session is, will the bill stay dead, or will the veto be overridden?

Support Us

The work of the Show-Me Institute would not be possible without the generous support of people who are inspired by the vision of liberty and free enterprise. We hope you will join our efforts and become a Show-Me Institute sponsor.

Donate
Man on Horse Charging