Tax Incentives, Bridges, and Jeff City in August

Governor Blunt has just set a date for a special session of the state legislature. It starts on August 20 and will deal with the economic development package that the governor rightfully vetoed, and the issue of bonding requirements for very long-term transportation projects. The economic development part would have gotten all the press if not for the recent tragedy in Minneapolis.

The issue with the performance bonds is fairly straightforward. MoDOT wants contractors to bid on repairing a group of 800 bridges, and then maintaining them for 25 years. As the bid process moved forward, it became apparent that the bonding requirements for the contractors, as currently set by law, would be too enormous in a 25-year project for any contractor to be able to afford it. So the Legislature and Governor Blunt need to make a few changes to reduce the performance bonds for long-term projects such as the Safe-and-Sound Bridge Improvement Plan. This is a great plan for Missouri, and I commend the Governor and Legislature for addressing it seriously.

The Snow Cones of Summer

Sauce magazine is a great part of our area’s literary and journalism scene. In this month’s issue, it has a wonderful article on the popularity of snow cones in St. Louis. The article does a perfect job of bringing out how the people who run snow cone stands are entrepreneurs in the purest form. The key to success in this business is in some pretty basic timing. You don’t see snow cone stands open in the winter. In fact, one of the stands I sometimes visit on S. Laclede Station Road turns into a Christmas tree lot each winter. Owners expand hours when its hot out (they are possibly the only people who like heat waves), and close early when it’s cold or raining. Other than that, it’s location, location, location.

When I was in high school and college, on several occasions I spent the summer working at Rio Syrup Co. This is one of the nation’s largest sno-cone syrup manufacturers, based right here in mid-town, by AG Edwards Wachovia. My great friend Bill Tomber is quoted extensively in the Sauce article. As someone who has lifted thousands of cases of cherry syrup onto trucks in my life, I can vouch for his statement on the popularity of that flavor:

What’s behind St. Louisans’ appetite for cherry snow cones? “It’s kind of a default flavor. It’s red, it’s bright ? it’s a good-tasting flavor, but you sort of know what you’re getting,” said Tomber.

So whether your are at Tower Tee, at a Cardinals game, in Old Webster, or anywhere else with one of the hundreds of snow cone stands in our area, enjoy a snow cone this summer and think about all the creative entrepreneurship that goes into every slurp!

911 24/7

Last one on 911 services for awhile, I promise. But the fine gentlemen at Missouri Political News Service, well aware of my recent obsession with the issue, alerted me to this story in the Kirksville Daily Express.  It seems that the local officials who run the area’s 911 service have taken a proposed tax increase off of the ballot precisely because they hope a tax is passed statewide and they can get their money that way, without taxing their own community! Just because you are paranoid does not mean someone isn’t out to get you. … From the article: 

That could turn voters off to the idea of another tax, but if the cell phone fee passes it could mean additional revenue for local 911 services, and could offset some of the difference needed to fund the E-911 service.

Now, I should clarify a few things here to give the full story. First of all, it is clear from the article that Adair County has current 911 service, which its citizens pay for, unlike some other rural counties that don’t have it at all and would now get it on everyone else’s cell bill dime. Second, they appear to have a countywide system, shared with the towns within the county, so if that’s correct, they deserve credit for it. But it does not appear from the article that the new money is needed for cell phone tracking, which is what I argued was a fair use of shared, statewide tax dollars. If their local system needs upgrades, the first option should be further consolidation with other counties, not hoping to get more money from the rest of the state.

More on the Midwives – I Mean, the Tocologists

Missouri midwives are preparing to appeal after Circuit Judge Patricia Joyce ruled the midwife provision unconstitutional:

The Senate tucked the midwifery provision into the health insurance bill in May. Few legislators knew the bill contained the amendment because of the way it was characterized. The sponsor, Sen. John Loudon, R-Chesterfield, used an obscure Greek term, “tocology,” to refer to midwifery. […]

“The midwife provision does not relate to health insurance,” Joyce wrote in her 19-page ruling.

She said that because legislators didn’t amend the bill’s title, “legislators were not on notice that a new subject, the practice of unregulated midwifery, had been added” to the bill.

I would be sad about this because I’m in favor of allowing midwifery. But I’m the kind of person who looks for silver linings in clouds, at least in legal battles. This must be great advertising for the midwives. And now everyone paying any attention to the news in Missouri knows the meaning of the word “tocology.” However effective that trick was this legislative session, no legislator will be able to claim ignorance of the word in the future!

What Should We Do About Uninsured Kids?

A letter in the Springfield News-Leader complains about the number of uninsured children in Missouri:

The SCHIP program provided health coverage for 6 million kids in 2006. Under the new bill, an additional 5 million children will be eligible for coverage, for a total of 11 million kids. 121,000 children in Missouri lack health insurance today, ironically in part because Rep. Blunt’s son, Gov. Matt Blunt, has stuck to family tradition and cut 1,903 in Greene County from Medicaid since 2005. A disturbing trend, which begs the question: What does the Blunt family have against children?

It’s a mistake to focus on insurance when what really matters is how many children receive medical care. Some parents who could afford insurance choose to pay for their children’s health care out-of-pocket instead. And for those who can’t afford insurance, there are ways to provide medical services directly, such as public clinics or vouchers for preventative care.

Worrying about providing health insurance for all kids is like worrying about providing car insurance for all kids. Some parents can afford cars and car insurance, and they drive their kids to school. Other kids take the bus.

We want all kids to have health care, but not everyone needs to go through insurance. And we certainly don’t need everyone to go through one government insurance program.

The Riverfront Times Adds to the 911 Discussion …

The Riverfront Times chimes into the 911 discussion with an interesting article on technical glitches and financial disputes that have possibly hampered 911 service in St. Louis County. I say “possibly” because the county maintains there has been no problem. This article discusses everything from technical issues to patent disputes to monetary fights — enough to make you long for a return to the days of hunting, gathering, worshipping the sun, and getting eaten by wild animals. Key statement (emphasis added):

McCormack has saved two months’ worth of calls to St. Louis County’s main dispatch center, which serves forty of the county’s municipalities, including larger areas such as Chesterfield and Eureka.

Another good example, along with the ones we discussed the other day, of shared municipal services. I found a crazy cool website dedicated to radio frequencies and 911 dispatch information. It shows that a number of county municipalities share 911 dispatch services with other cities, but we still have way too many separate systems in St. Louis County. For the record, Olivette has joined the East Central Dispatch system in Richmond Heights that I discussed the other day, so kudos to them. Most of the larger cities have their own dispatch systems (Florissant, University City), which is fine — they are big enough to afford it.

There are some typical examples of too much redundancy in the county, though. It’s nice that Glendale and Warson Woods share the dispatch system, but if Kirkwood does dispatching for Oakland, it can certainly do it for Glendale and Warson Woods, too. Same with Brentwood and Rock Hill. Why not just save money for everyone and join the East Central Dispatch system? Ladue, Frontenac, and Huntleigh?  How about some more coooperation here?

For the record, in my recent posts on St. Ann I wondered whether they were doing all they could to share services, as opposed to raising taxes. It seems that, in 911 dispatch at least, they are indeed sharing the service with a couple of other mid-sized munis, so they deserve credit for that.

As I wrote earlier, any new tax imposed to improve 911 service should mandate some consolidation of dispatch centers before the additional money is distributed. Then I will gladly vote for the cell phone tax.

Adequacy Lawsuits Reinforce Poor Educational Policy

As part of a growing trend seen across the United States, several school districts in Missouri continue to perform poorly, failing to prepare students for higher education. Following the Saint Louis Public Schools’ recent loss of accreditation, Missourians want to see change and improvement more than ever. Concern for Missouri’s public school system, however, is not a new development. The past 50 years have seen the rise of several theories on how to promote educational quality — among them, a competitive parental choice environment, which fosters incentives for educators to improve school quality. Unfortunately, the recent adequacy lawsuit trend mistakenly focuses on money, rather than encouraging changes that are needed to improve Missouri schools. To help the public schools succeed, Missouri should focus on incentive-based reforms like parental choice, rather than adequacy litigation.

Adequacy lawsuits have quickly gained popularity among school administrators and educators. The suits claim that current state funding cannot provide an “adequate” education for students, and prescribe a solution: give school districts more money. Although a current adequacy case in Missouri is still pending, several cases in other states — and an older equity case in Missouri — have favored the plaintiffs, granting more money to school districts. This type of substantial increase in financial resources is understandably appealing to many education supporters, but does not lead to the type of restructuring needed to truly change the education system. The amount of funding is not nearly as critical as the way that funding is spent. Until reforms are enacted that change the latter, current conditions will persist.

A statistically significant relationship between expenditure and student performance has yet to be consistently demonstrated. This should not be surprising; when schools receive additional funding despite disappointing educational outcomes and little promise of positive future developments, school officials lack the incentive to develop programs that will improve student performance. When schools are rewarded in spite of failure, they will only continue to misallocate resources to programs that are not in their students’ best interests.

Adequacy litigation not only fails to improve student performance but also costs the state and its taxpayers. A study released in July 2007 by the Tax Foundation discusses the fiscal impact of school finance litigation in the U.S. According to the study, nine out of 27 states ordered to increase educational funding did so by increasing taxes by $13 billion annually. Missouri is among these nine states. The study also points out that “even a hefty, short-term increase in education spending to comply with a court order does not always translate into permanently higher levels of spending.”

Rather than tolerating an approach that rewards poor performance, officials need to push for reforms that increase parental involvement, teacher quality, and students’ motivation to learn. An education system that allows parents to choose the schools their children attend will lead not only to a higher level of parental involvement, but also to better schools. As several school choice studies discuss, increased competition encourages all schools to provide higher educational quality in their efforts to attract students. When faced with competition from other schools, educators will allocate funds to programs with the most successful outcomes, because failure to do this will give parents an incentive to send their children to better-performing schools. Schools with a poor performance record will lose funding. This type of market-based reform motivates officials to improve educational standards while efficiently using resources.

While school choice reforms would take more time and effort than a simple increase in funding, they are necessary to turn underperforming schools into an educational system that will successfully prepare Missouri students for higher education and a competitive labor market.

Kathleen Navin is an intern with the Show-Me Institute, a Missouri think tank, and a graduate student in economics at the University of Missouri-Columbia.

 

Quick Updates All Around …

The last few days of the Post-Dispatch have brought a number of updates to things I have been writing about, so how about some quick links and thoughts? Sounds fun, huh? You think you hate this idea now, but wait until you read it!

In a response to fiscal problems caused by a decline in sales at Northwest Plaza, St. Ann has decided to put a large utility tax increase on the ballot. Prediction: It will lose badly, just like the tax increases on the ballot yesterday in our area all did. My thoughts: Utility tax increases are a particularly terrible idea — balancing a budget on the backs of people trying to pay for the basic necessities of life. A general property tax increase would be better than this. At least that would be tax deductible for state and federal income taxes, practically speaking.

University City will be installing red light cameras at Big Bend and Hanley on Delmar. Regular readers (both of you) will recall my hatred of these things. I was going to speak against them at the city council meeting on Monday, but my hatred of red light cameras ran up against my love of going to Cardinals games. As my family has long known, the Cardinals always win those battles. So we have red light cameras now, but at least I saw a 10-run inning and took my son, Nate, to his first game. In the interest of full disclosure, I was heading to play tennis last night, driving northbound on Hanley at Delmar, when I stopped in the right lane for the yellow and the driver next to me completely blew the red. He certainly deserved something for that move.

Missouri and Illinois are slowly getting closer to an agreement on a new Mississippi River Bridge. This is good news, and I look forward to the final agreement — which I understand, for better or worse, will not be using tolls. 

I appreciated the feedback and critiques from the gentlemen at Missouri Political News Service on my post about 911 systems and expansion. I am always happy to defend my posts and discuss my ideas, and am open to hearing new thoughts and opinions on what I write about.

Finally, I am just gonna give a general credit to Combest, as I linked to a lot of articles here and I almost certainly got some most every one of them from his great website.

What to Do With the Budget Surplus

An op-ed in the Springfield News-Leader argues that Missouri shouldn’t spend its budget surplus:

To fairly address this excess, the government should either refund the $320 million to taxpayers or pass comprehensive tax cuts for all Missourians.

I think the second option is much better policy. If you give people a one-time rebate, they’ll spend the money or put in in the bank, then go back to business as usual. But if you cut taxes, people will change their plans, investing more in education and capital because they expect to reap higher after-tax returns. That can have effects far into the future.

Support Us

The work of the Show-Me Institute would not be possible without the generous support of people who are inspired by the vision of liberty and free enterprise. We hope you will join our efforts and become a Show-Me Institute sponsor.

Donate
Man on Horse Charging