The Best Ideas for Fixing U.S. Schools, Part 1

In September, The New York Times published 30 Ideas for Fixing U.S. Schools, Ranked by Experts. The paper surveyed 37 national experts on education policy, and I was one of them. We were asked to evaluate policy ideas based on their potential to improve student performance and their cost.

This is the first of two posts discussing the findings. Here, I focus on two of the ideas where I agree with the expert consensus. Part two of this post addresses one where I disagree.

I wholeheartedly agree with the panel’s top two “best value” picks: the science of reading and school accountability. These policies are no-brainers. They are relatively inexpensive and have proven track records of success.

States with strong accountability systems and a commitment to the science of reading outperform states without these policies on national assessments. And states that have recently implemented major reforms in these areas have climbed rapidly in national rankings. The evidence is clear: Children in states with strong accountability and science of reading policies learn more in school.

The New York Times article also emphasizes a critical point: Good policies only work when they are implemented well.

Half-baked accountability based on inaccurate or unclear data, with poor communication and no consequences, is hardly accountability. Similarly, a literacy policy that gives a nod to the science of reading, but lacks urgency and is not comprehensive, cannot be expected to fundamentally alter a state’s literacy trajectory.

On accountability, Missouri is moving in the right direction. Following Governor Kehoe’s January 2026 executive order, the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE) will soon publish simple, easy-to-understand letter grades for schools and districts based on student outcomes. For the first time, Missourians will receive clearly communicated information about objective academic performance in our schools. We can do more, but these report cards are a critical first step toward a robust system of school accountability.

Missouri is in worse shape when it comes to literacy policy. We do not administer a common statewide literacy assessment, we have no clear literacy standard for promotion into the fourth grade, and we continue to allow teacher preparation programs that promote ineffective reading instruction to certify teachers to work in Missouri schools. Meaningful reforms to address these shortcomings gained considerable momentum with lawmakers during the 2026 legislative session, but ultimately fell short.

Missouri is making meaningful progress on school accountability. Now we need to bring that same commitment to literacy policy. I’ll be making the case for these reforms again in 2027.

Taxation Without Representation at the Special School District

The Special School District (SSD) of St. Louis County provides public education for children with special needs throughout St. Louis County and portions of Jefferson County. It is one of two special school districts in Missouri, with the other one being Pemiscot County. (Why Pemiscot County has its own countywide special school district is a topic for another blog post.) Some St. Louis and Jefferson County residents who may not have been that familiar with the district are about to become more familiar, as it just raised its tax rates substantially without a vote of the people.

In September, SSD approved a new property tax rate of $1.1996 per $100 of assessed valuation, compared with $0.8993 last year. That is an increase of 30 cents in the stated tax rate—a one-third tax increase. The district justified the increase through a tax recoupment calculation intended to recover revenue lost because of previous property assessment adjustments, such as being required to roll back rates when assessments increase. It’s getting a lot of attention over the past few days, due to a software glitch at the county collector’s office that created numerous errors in tax bills, including doubling SSD’s tax increase on some bills (the county claims those errors are now being corrected). But the correct tax increases are still bad.

Missouri law generally places important restrictions on the ability of local governments to increase property taxes without voter approval. These protections are intended to prevent government revenues from automatically expanding simply because property values rise. Taxpayers should have a meaningful voice when government seeks additional revenue.

Missouri Revised Statutes §§ 162.920 and 137.073.5(4) specifically provide for voter approval of increases in special school district tax rates, but also make allowances for local governments to raise property taxes in some instances without a vote of the people. Whether SSD’s recent recoupment adjustment falls within its previously authorized taxing authority is a separate legal question. But something can be legally permissible and still represent terrible public policy.

Consider the impact on homeowners. The average home in St. Louis County is valued at $285,000. A thirty-cent property tax rate increase results in a $162 tax increase. These increases come on top of the numerous other property taxes imposed by school districts, municipalities, counties, and special taxing districts.

The district will undoubtedly point to its financial needs. SSD currently faces an $83 million budget deficit and is under state audit. Those figures warrant serious attention. But financial challenges do not eliminate the need for fiscal discipline or taxpayer accountability.

Before increasing taxes, government agencies should thoroughly examine spending priorities, administrative costs, staffing, and opportunities for greater efficiency. More importantly, they should make their case directly to voters.

There is also a broader problem. Missouri has hundreds of overlapping local taxing jurisdictions. When each government entity can increase its levy through complicated calculations that ordinary taxpayers struggle to understand, meaningful accountability becomes increasingly difficult.

The Missouri Legislature should examine the recoupment provisions that permit substantial tax-rate adjustments without a new public vote. House Bill 660 in 2025 attempted to do this exact thing. The city of Town and Country recently did something similar to what SSD is doing when it instituted a city property tax, which had been at zero for twenty years, without a vote of the people under the same legal justification.

The SSD should be held to the same fundamental principle that ought to govern every taxing authority: If government needs substantially more money, it should explain why and ask the voters. Taxing districts are figuring out ways around the Hancock Amendment, and this allowance for tax increases without public votes needs to be addressed.

Who’s in Charge of Missouri’s Schools? with Cory Koedel

Susan Pendergrass talks with Cory Koedel, director of education policy at the Show-Me Institute, about who is in charge of public education in Missouri after the state commissioner’s resignation, the state’s new school letter grades, and why Koedel says the state needs to keep testing. They also discuss their new paper, Missouri Education Policy with Reduced Federal Oversight, including why Koedel believes Title I funding is poorly designed and what a different approach could look like, and more.

Read the report

Listen on Spotify

Listen on Apple Podcasts 

Listen on SoundCloud

Episode Transcript

Susan Pendergrass (00:00)

This is gonna be an interesting podcast because it’s kind of a meta one where I’m joined by Cory Koedel, director of education policy at the Show-Me Institute, as well as a professor of economics at Mizzou, and we wrote a paper together recently on the federal role in public education policy at the state level. But what I wanna talk about before we get into that paper is like what’s going on in terms of, you know, where does the buck stop right now in public education? Because there’s been a lot of upheaval in Missouri at the state level, let alone what’s happening at the federal level. So what is going on right now in terms of leadership of public education in Missouri? Can you just update us?

Cory Koedel (00:41)

Yeah, so it’s nice to be on the podcast as always. What’s going on with the Department of Education right now, as you know, the interim commissioner Stacey Preis resigned after the last board meeting, which I guess was a couple of weeks ago now. And they’re in the process of looking to replace her. You know, if you ask where the buck stops, I think the short answer where the buck stops right now is with the State Board of Education.

Susan Pendergrass (01:06)

Okay, let’s just go back to why Stacey Preis was in there. So the State Board of Education has been somewhat reconfigured and there was a commissioner of education who left last summer. What happened there? Do you know?

Cory Koedel (01:20)

So over the summer there were several very contentious board meetings and an especially contentious meeting between the board and the former commissioner Karla Eslinger. I believe the June board meeting was the really contentious one, but you could just, if you listen to it, it’s kinda long and boring, but there was a stretch in there where you could really get a sense of it and you could feel the heat rising. And shortly after that board meeting, Karla resigned. And the Board of Education brought Stacey Preis in and she has been serving as the interim commissioner since. There was really no expectation she would stay on as permanent. It wasn’t even clear she would have wanted that job, but she was gonna fill in and keep things running since then. And then so the new news was her resignation, which was a bit of a surprise in October. And all the while the board is working toward getting a permanent commissioner in place.

Susan Pendergrass (02:11)

And then one of the big things that’s happening and has been happening this year is that DESE, as led by the commissioner, is supposed to be putting out letter grades for schools and districts. Is that what’s tripping up these commissioners?

Cory Koedel (02:24)

So again, we’re speculating here a little bit. I think with Karla, I do not think that was what tripped her up. I do think the board and Dr. Preis were not getting along very well, it didn’t seem like, and the letter grades were an issue that was coming up at the board meetings and clearly the sides were not getting along very well about it. To say that was the thing that caused it. I think actually someone might have asked her if that was what caused her to resign. And I think she did say no in my Marie. She had a brief press conference. So I’m not sure that I would stick it to the letter grades. I know that’s been a stressful issue for a lot of folks in Missouri and of course right there at the decision making part between the board and DESE, that’s been an issue. But I would say it’s a stretch to say that is what caused the resignation.

Susan Pendergrass (03:12)

Well, I say where does the buck stop? Because, you know, we’re gonna be talking about the fact that at the federal level, the current administration wants to air quote send education back to the state. So they’re like, We are not even supposed to be involved, it’s really a state issue. Then I hear at the state level, especially in that June meeting that you mentioned, some folks at the state level saying, Yeah, we’re a local control state. It really goes down to the superintendents and the principals and the building. And now we have the governor mandating these letter grades for schools and districts. And already in the media I’m seeing superintendents say, pay no attention to the letter grades, they don’t really tell you anything, we say like in a sense undermining that issue. And then it’s hard to know. Like who is in like if I’m unhappy with the way things are going with public education in Missouri, who should I be trying to hold responsible for that?

Cory Koedel (04:02)

So two things I’ll say. One is, you know, amidst all this chaos, I think it’s important to just point out directly these letter grades I think are quite good. So, you know, folks at the Show-Me Institute have been talking about the need for this for a long time. If you don’t like our ideas, you can look at other states that have really had recent success in their education systems. They have several things that they’re doing really well, but one of them is serious accountability and letter grades for schools and districts. It’s an important component of success in a lot of states. And Governor Kehoe’s executive order that brought the letter grades in is really well written. It’s really nice. And there’s not a bunch of fluff in there. It’s about student outcomes. You know, you’re always gonna get the school systems complaining about it and telling you, you know, there’s other stuff, and of course there’s other stuff, but the most important thing about schools is what the students are learning. I hope. I don’t know. I feel that’s true. I hope that’s not too controversial. And the letter grades are based on those things. And so I think the letter grade stuff is quite nice. And, you know, despite Stacey Preis resigning, things are going forward with report cards, and my understanding is they’re gonna release preliminary grades as soon as next month, maybe in December, and then they’re gonna release the first official grades next year. So that’s all happening. To answer your question of who you should be looking to if you’re not happy with how education policy is happening right now in the state of Missouri, I think there’s two places you can look. One is our state legislature, and in particular, to be blunt, the Senate has been dysfunctional and not really doing much of anything and blocking reform. I mean, there’s a lot of controversy around some of these reforms. So I know you and I are both pro-school choice. We’d like a bigger MOScholars program, more charter schools. I get that stuff’s controversial. An area where things are much less controversial is literacy reform, making sure we’re implementing policies so our kids can read. The Senate’s not allowing that to happen either, even though my sense is there’s broad bipartisan support for this. So we have some legislative gridlock, to put it nicely, with stuff not getting done. So if you want to be upset at folks there, I think that’s very reasonable in our state senate. And then on the administration side, I really do think the state school board has taken a much more assertive role than historically has been the case. My view until very recently of our state school board is it’s been a rubber stamp for whatever DESE wants to do. That’s different now, and they are pushing to do things. And I think with that comes some accountability for what’s happening.

Susan Pendergrass (06:37)

Yeah, I think that, you know, twenty years ago No Child Left Behind got rolled out. There was a lot of backlash to this idea that we’re gonna test every kid, report the tests, and every school’s gonna be accredited or not accredited and was really top down, heavy handed from the federal government. And people didn’t like it. And they eventually watered it all down and waived everything. But there was some aspect of that that also kind of works, right? Like people don’t like feeling like they’re being told how to run their classroom. But at the same time when you don’t do that, kids learn less. Is that fair?

Cory Koedel (07:11)

Susan, I think you’re understating it even. I mean, look, it was unpleasant, but it worked. And to be honest, we all understand that happens all the time in life. There’s all kinds of unpleasant things we go through that work to get things done. And, you know, there’s some pretty well-identified research evidence that suggests that some of what happened under No Child Left Behind, some of the accountability pressures really did improve student learning. And there’s also just broad evidence that that was a period when No Child Left Behind was in place where achievement really took off in this country. And right around when they softened it all and pulled it all back is when achievement started declining. Now other stuff happened as well when things started declining. So you want to be a little careful about overinterpreting those trends, but all of the evidence suggests it worked. It’s just a matter of degree. And our school system has been struggling ever since we repealed all that accountability.

Susan Pendergrass (08:03)

So I feel like in Missouri now we have a similar kind of push pull where we have a more active board. They’re gonna hold the commissioner accountable in a way that really hasn’t been happening. And we have these kind of top down policies. And you know, as you mentioned, in the Missouri legislature, particularly the Senate, even the simplest thing is like, let’s not use a harmful approach to teaching reading, there’s pushback, right? They’re like, Well, you can’t tell us what we can and can’t do in the classroom. What do we do about that?

Cory Koedel (08:29)

So there was that pushback against some of the literacy reforms and what you’re referring to is the three-cueing method of teaching kids how to read. It’s been debunked, it just it doesn’t teach kids how to read. And there is some pushback. There was legislation to try to ban the use of three-cueing in schools, and there was some pushback against banning it that it could be bad for teachers. I think we could talk about that. You know, the truth is, Susan, I’m not too worried about that because I don’t feel like that was very effective during the legislative session. I think there was testimony. I was there at some of the bill hearings and testimony was given that we shouldn’t take any tools away from teachers and you know, how dare us try and tell a teacher what they can and can’t do. But I do feel like that largely fell flat with the lawmakers. They understood that this wasn’t a good way to teach reading and things were progressing along. I think things stalled out because our Senate just refused to do anything. They refused to let any bills through in education. So I’m not as worried about the coalition of folks who just don’t want anything to change in schools, I don’t think their ideas are so effective as much as we just have gridlock in our Senate.

Susan Pendergrass (09:39)

Yeah, but there has been either through bills that have been filed or just through the rumor mill, some suggestion that maybe we don’t even need a state education agency, let alone a federal education agency. And if we go that route, that like the state shouldn’t be telling us what test to use route, then we are going to not only throw out No Child Left Behind gains, but we’re gonna throw out gains from the Missouri assessment program, right? Like we’re gonna go back to when I was in school and everyone just took the Iowa Tests of Basic Skills. Your parents got a piece of paper and said, I guess it looks okay. And that was that, right? Like, that to me seems like a possibility and also a real risk for the kids in Missouri.

Cory Koedel (10:24)

Yeah, I think it’s a scary idea. It is circulating in some places in Jeff City. What I always tell people is, if you’re not happy about how our schools are running right now, just wait till we stop testing. And I think whatever else is happening, if we stop testing, then we just have no more objective information about what’s happening. And that’s true. Some people don’t understand the nuance, that’s true even if we are testing, but all the districts are using different tests. If we let them all pick their own tests, we have no way to compare across districts and understand what’s going on and which schools are succeeding, which need supports, and all the stuff that we would have to do to try to have a functioning education system in Missouri. The test data provide really valuable information, and it’s really important that we keep testing.

Susan Pendergrass (11:10)

And that’s basically for the most part what these report cards will be based on as the foundation of that is this MAP test. And I know you’ve been really involved in the process, but what do you see happening when the grades, maybe not this set that’s coming out in November, December, but the air quotes real ones that come out next year, how do you see that, what kind of impact do you think that will have on the districts that get D’s and F’s and also even on the districts that get the A’s? How do you see that all kind of sifting out once we get to look at these grades?

Cory Koedel (11:40)

Well, that’s the million dollar question. What I would say the big problem the grades are solving is what in the educational research community we call the honesty gap. And the honesty gap is that kids get grades from their teachers that are all A’s and Bs, but their test scores show they’re not proficient. They’re not able to do these academic skills that they’re supposed to be able to do. And the letter grades for the schools and districts are based on the tests. And so the first thing that I think is surely going to happen is a lot of people are going to be surprised. And I know this because there’s a lot of survey data out there. When you ask parents, hey, like how is your kid doing in school? And, you know, 80% of parents say my kid’s doing great. And then, you know, only 40% of kids are proficient. And so there is this huge gap. There’s gonna be a lot of surprises when this happens. And you know, right now the Missouri letter grade policy really doesn’t have any teeth. It’s not like if you get an F, the state’s gonna come take over the school or anything, you know, wild like that. It’s just informational. But I think that could be quite powerful because I think it’s gonna lead people to ask questions. And what I feel fairly confident about is when they ask questions, they’re gonna realize that the letter grades are giving them meaningful information. You know, you’ve alluded to some district correspondence, ignore these grades, don’t worry about it, they don’t mean anything. Anyone who takes the time to look is gonna see they may not like their grade, but it’s based on real data on how kids are doing on tests and a strong academic growth measure that Missouri has that allows us to compare similar schools. And it’s gonna change the conversation, I think, about school quality in our state and where it goes from there, I’m not sure, but it’s the obvious first step.

Susan Pendergrass (13:23)

So we have a paper that’s just been released that’s not related to that exactly, but it’s related to the federal role in Jefferson City, which to the extent that folks when they send their kids off to school on the school bus every morning think about the state role, I don’t think they do. But they certainly probably don’t think about the federal role. But when this Trump administration came in, one of the things that they pledged to do was to get rid of the Department of Education and that requires Congress. So it has not happened and is not expected to happen. But the Department of Education said to states, Hey, send us your ideas for any federal law that you’d like us to waive and we want you guys to have flexibility and not just be complying with the you know, filling out forms and just complying. We do have a lot of people in Jefferson City whose salaries are paid by federal funds, basically, and they do a lot of form filling and a lot of certification on these contracts. It takes a lot of time. And they said, you know, we’re gonna try to, if you wanna take that on yourself, we’ll give you maximum flexibility. But basically what did we find out? I mean, I can tell you what we found out to a certain extent, but were you surprised that there’s not much there?

Cory Koedel (14:34)

Yeah, so that was, you know, when you do these research projects, you know, obviously you’re trying to produce a product that can teach other people things. But a lot of times you learn stuff on the way yourself and it’s a learning process, you know, for the writer. And that was certainly true in this paper. And it was kind of shocking to me how little. As you mentioned, the federal Department of Education is saying, you know, send us requests for waivers, we’ll help you out, we’ll do this stuff for ya. Just in plain terms, they can hardly do anything. The amount that they can really help you with is like a rounding error in terms of the dollars. They can help you, you know, streamline the little bureaucracy, you know, get rid of a few of these paper pushers. It sounds nice because no one wants someone sitting there just filling out forms all day. It seems like a waste of time, but in the scheme of our education budget it’s like nothing. And the big things that would really help us, you know, one thing I learned from our project is, you know, the Department of Education can’t help us. Congress has to act and I’m not very optimistic about that in the short run, but someone has to push them and they have to act for real meaningful changes to happen.

Susan Pendergrass (15:36)

Yeah, I didn’t have a very strong reaction to this idea that they’re gonna get rid of the Department of Education. I remember just after the election, somebody saying, my god, this is amazing. They’re gonna get rid of the Department of Education. I’m so excited. And I said, You’re gonna be disappointed. And then other people were like, my god, kids won’t get lunch, there won’t be money for kids with disabilities. And I said, You’re gonna be really disappointed because really you probably wouldn’t even notice all of those functions happen. Well, the Department of Education came into being in the eighties, but it’s basically governed by a law passed in the sixties. So whether there’s a building which they’ve moved out of, or whether there’s letterhead, department of education, doesn’t change the fact that sixty years ago Congress passed a law on sending money to states for districts that serve higher numbers or percentages of poor kids. And that law, I can’t even imagine Congress taking it up ’cause it would be so difficult to ever come to consensus again. I mean at some point it’s like rewriting a state constitution. At some point they need to do something, but it’s so big and unwieldy that I just can’t even imagine it changing. And as long as that law’s in place, really there’s not much flexibility.

Cory Koedel (16:43)

Yeah, and what you’re talking about specifically is the funding and mostly what we call Title I funding, which is funding that the federal government allocates to districts in poorer areas. And it’s been around for a long time and that’s the thing the State Department of Education can’t do anything about. If we sent a wonderful request of a great idea of how to repurpose that money, distribute it in a smarter way, the Department of Education can do absolutely nothing to help us. Congress would have to act to give us that flexibility. But you know, I mentioned like learning while you’re doing these research reports. The epiphany I had in working on this with you, you know, and I will say I’m a strong advocate of the government allocating more resources to low-income schools. I think that the low-income kids, to be more specific, I think that’s really important redistribution service of the government. And I’m very in favor of it, and I actually would like to redistribute even more than we do. But my epiphany is I’m very anti-Title I. The way this program is set up is terrible. And if you don’t mind me going a little bit on a tangent,

Susan Pendergrass (17:48)

No, please.

Cory Koedel (17:50)

Just as an analogy for Title I, the way Title I allocates money is it identifies schools and districts in poor areas and it sends them an allotment every year and no matter what happens they just get an allotment every year. I mean there’s a formula that’s complicated, but every year they just get a dump of money and that’s the federal government’s solution to try to help with poverty. And it made me think of years ago I was brought on as a consultant at a major philanthropic foundation and they had a huge endowment, well over a billion dollars and the top people at the foundation were very worried that they were wasting their money, that they weren’t doing any good. And the main threat that they identified is the way these big foundations work. When they’re a nonprofit, they have an endowment and they get tax advantages for that and the trade-off is they have to spend a certain amount of money and I think it’s about five percent. And a lot of them will spend the minimum. So say this endowment spins off five percent every year. So on a billion dollars, that’s fifty million, fifty million dollars a year. So every year on January 1st, 50 million dollars drops in your lap. No matter how good or bad of a job you do, next January 1st, 50 million drops in your lap. And they were so concerned about this. They thought this was the worst situation because no matter how poorly they did, there was no accountability for it. And the next year their program officers just get their coffers filled again and they could go waste the money the whole next year. So it was actually really nice and thoughtful, and I really enjoyed working with this foundation trying to figure this out. But the epiphany was that’s exactly how Title I works. So it just instead of philanthropic foundation, it’s just dumping money on schools in poor areas, no matter how bad of a job they do. If they don’t help the kids at all, if they hurt the kids, if someone embezzles the money, it just goes right back to me. It’s a fundamentally flawed system. And there is quite a bit of money in this to help low-income kids. And I just wish we could do something smarter about it. And of course, in the report we talk about what we’d like to do if Congress would let us.

Susan Pendergrass (19:43)

Yeah, it passed in 1965 and they started studying the impact of it in like 1968. Like immediately they started trying to find out if this program was having an impact, and they have studied it consistently over the last sixty years. And there is very, very thin evidence that there’s been any impact for any particular group of kids that’s lasted. It is for the amount of money that’s been spent, it is troubling what you cannot show has happened. And there’s no real stick or carrot. There’s a threat that if you don’t comply with reporting requirements, maybe they would withhold funds, but funds have never been withheld. In sixty years, funds have never been withheld for anything. And you know, so I think everyone knows that. And honestly, no district really has any way of checking the amount of money they get either because the formulas are so complicated and depend on all the other districts. So, you know, it’s just kind of like money going into a hole. Now in our paper we talk about a solution that has been talked about for decades now, which is turn it into the Pell Grant system, just attach it to a child living below the poverty line, which we can now easily identify these kids. We have direct certification. We know if they’re getting SNAP or CHIP. We know who these kids are, and just give them the money directly to take to school. It would have to be a school of their choice because there would have to be some incentive there. But, you know, in Missouri I think kids living below the poverty line could get fifteen hundred dollars for example and if they could choose their school, they would come with fifteen hundred dollars or their parents could use it as a scholarship account, you know, for a computer or tutoring or something else. But again, Congress which does less and less all the time would have to act and really go back and tackle that. Now there has been in the last 10 or 15 years a couple of instances where a pilot program to do that almost got through, but it didn’t get through. So a state would have to apply for a waiver and say we would like to do a pilot in two districts or three districts, and that didn’t happen. The best chance for that was under No Child Left Behind. And they ended up with something called supplemental education services. So that’s not gonna happen. So Missouri just gets the money, it funds. I don’t know, I think I figured out thirty or forty salaries in Jefferson City are paid for with federal funds and that’s just the way it’s gonna be and there’s really no incentive to change that. Which is kind of a bummer.

Cory Koedel (22:10)

Yeah, so a couple of reactions to that. So the first thing I wanna mention is you mentioned it’s fifteen hundred dollars, which knowledgeable folks paying attention are gonna say, Well that’s not that much money to educate a student and that’s true, but you know it could be combined with smart state policies like something like MOScholars, where if you’re a low income family in Missouri, you get priority access to MOScholars, which is our education savings account program, and you could top it off with federal funding and then those poor students would have a higher dollar value attached to them, which could help open up more options for them. I also think there’s other creative ways you could think about using that what we call backpacking the fund. So attaching the fund to the kid so the kid can use it what makes sense. I mean ’cause I think one issue that some of these families have is transportation. And you can imagine some interesting transportation ideas coming up using this funding to help these kids get to a school that’s better for them. And there’s all kinds of things we could do if we had the leeway to do it. I will say I’m a little skeptical about even a pilot showing the potential of this thing, because of course the pilot wouldn’t come with the broad infrastructure change that you could build around this, that would be good. So, you know, it is, you know, I guess we’re a little bit pie in the sky here ’cause I think we both agree that Congress is unlikely to take this up soon. The other reaction I have that I want to mention is I also want to be very clear. You know, we’re sitting here in our little siloed world thinking this is a great idea. There’s obvious losers of such a policy change, and that’s these districts that every year just get this pile of money dropped in their lap and they would mount a vicious defense against any changes to the plan. So it’d be very hard politically as well, but it became apparent to me in working on this that the current system just doesn’t make any sense. And as you pointed out, there’s really no evidence that it does any good. And for as much money as we spent on this thing, that’s pretty damning in itself.

Susan Pendergrass (23:58)

There is a big belief in Title I-A, though, and a big cheerleading section for all the good that it does because it goes to poor schools and it’s supposed to supplement, not supplant, so it can’t be like the state doesn’t send the money. I mean, it’s supposed to be money on top of all the other money, but folks are very disappointed to find out that there’s no evidence that it’s had an impact. I mean, we know that the gap in achievement between poor kids and non poor kids only gets wider. It has not narrowed. And that was the whole point of this program when Lyndon Johnson put his name on it. So are you optimistic about things that are happening at the state level in Missouri?

Cory Koedel (24:33)

You know, I think I am. I think it’s rocky right now. I think the commissioner turnover stuff has not been good. But what I will say, when I step back from it, you know, I moved here in ’07 and have been at the University of Missouri this whole time and recently with Show-Me, but my whole time here, I feel like our state board has been very apathetic. They didn’t seem to care about anything as our achievement was declining during the mid to late 2010s. I saw no urgency from anyone, things tanked during COVID, no urgency. What’s fundamentally different now is we have a state board that really does care. And I wish things the last few months would have gone down a little better. And I think there’s some mistakes they’ve made. But they care. And to me that’s actually a really huge step forward. And I’m optimistic that some of these missteps, they can learn from them and correct course and get on a better path and keep that caring. And we can try and make some progress and make things a little better for kids in our schools.

Susan Pendergrass (25:35)

I agree. And yeah, I know you and I have talked about this, but most people think the schools are doing fine, right? They think Missouri’s probably pretty great. I don’t know. But even since I’ve been working in Missouri for eight or nine years, Missouri’s gone from sort of top third to middle of the pack to moving to the bottom of the pack. And in the last round of national test scores that came out in 2024, I think it was fourth grade reading, we only beat New Mexico and Oregon. We were third from the bottom. And I think that that is shocking to people. I don’t think they realize that four in ten of our fourth graders are really not able to do any basic reading. So hopefully the board’s gonna, I mean, they’ve got a tough set of circumstances that they’re working within. So I’m glad that they’re not just complacent anymore.

Cory Koedel (26:22)

Yep, no, and this is the honesty gap we were talking about. And I’ve written recently about how this shows up in graduation rates. So during this decline you just described in our test scores over time falling, falling, falling, our graduation rate’s been going through the roof. And I do think that most people just don’t understand that our schools just are not performing well. I mean it’s just a fact. They’re just not performing well compared to other states, they’re not performing well compared to our own historical standards. Our kids are not learning as much as they should be in school. And yeah, it’s a tough thing.

Susan Pendergrass (26:55)

And we’ll keep working on it. And we do have a paper on the potential federal waivers that Missouri could be asking for at showmeinstitute.org. But thanks so much for joining me and discussing it.

Cory Koedel (27:06)

Thanks for having me.

Produced by Show-Me Opportunity

Missouri Again Earns Positive Marks for State Finances

Truth in Accounting (TIA) is out with its 2026 rating of state finances, and Missouri once again has earned a B grade from the Chicago-based non-profit. Last year I was cautious about the rating. This year, Missouri earned its third consecutive B and increased its Taxpayer Surplus™ from $200 to $500 per taxpayer.

The surplus represents the amount by which available assets exceed obligations under TIA’s methodology, including unfunded pensions and retiree healthcare, divided by the estimated number of taxpayers. The authors wrote, “Missouri maintained a positive financial condition, supported by higher tax revenues and lower liabilities, with only a modest reduction in pension liability.” This is good and represents a substantial improvement over time, though progress has been uneven. Missouri went from a $4,400 per-taxpayer shortfall in fiscal year (FY) 2020 to a $700 shortfall in FY 2022, followed by surpluses of $600 in FY 2023, $200 in FY 2024, and $500 in FY 2025.

There are still some caveats, some of which I discussed last year in a post on this topic. For example, federal grants accounted for 47% of Missouri’s 2025 revenue, or approximately $23.4 billion, second only to Louisiana’s 50%. That leaves Missouri particularly exposed to changes in federal funding. (The audit of that federal funding identified 16 findings that did not align with established standards, laws, or internal policies. Nine of those were repeated from previous audits.) Also, Missouri’s unfunded pension liabilities declined by only 4% despite strong investment returns. TIA attributes that modest improvement to higher-than-expected salaries and retiree cost-of-living adjustments, which offset gains.

Lastly, Missouri is slow to file its financial reports. TIA reports that Missouri released its financial report 235 days after the fiscal year ended—55 days beyond the six-month standard set by the Government Finance Officers Association. Missouri was hardly alone. Four states took more than 300 days after the fiscal year ended to release their reports, and four others still had not released them by TIA’s September 1 research cutoff.

Our positive financial standing is good news not just for us, but nationally. TIA’s numbers indicate 35 of the 46 rated states likewise improved. However, it’s important to recognize that TIA’s assessment of Missouri’s financial position is different from an assessment of the state’s annual budget. As my colleague and multiple state audits have noted, Missouri’s budget outlook remains troubling, with general revenue balances declining and spending continuing to exceed projected revenues. While Missouri’s improving financial position is welcome news, protecting taxpayers will require the state to rein in spending and put its budget on a sustainable path.

PETCO (As in Pets in Columbia, Not the Store)

The City of Columbia and Boone County are getting into the animal shelter business, and many questions remain.

On October 19, the Columbia City Council voted unanimously to purchase a building at 1300 Boone Industrial Drive for $995,000 to establish a city–county animal shelter. Columbia will pay $595,000, while Boone County will contribute $400,000. The decision represents a significant departure from the city’s longstanding relationship with the Central Missouri Humane Society, which has provided shelter services for years.

According to city officials, the decision followed a request from the Central Missouri Humane Society for $5.5 million to use for a new facility. The Humane Society has been providing animal care services under contract with the city and county. I can’t blame the city for rejecting that very large request from the Humane Society, but by ending the relationship with the Humane Society, Columbia has decided to purchase its own shelter.

Perhaps the most troubling aspect of the purchase is that the property reportedly had an earlier asking price of $675,000. A resident questioned why the city was now paying $995,000, but city officials did not provide a detailed explanation during the meeting. That’s a $320,000 difference that deserves an answer.

In my recent report for the Show-Me Institute on the topic of municipal public health operations, I examined how Missouri municipalities provide animal control and shelter services. The research demonstrates that cities have numerous alternatives to direct government operation. I give some credit to Columbia and Boone County for working together on this instead of operating separately, and according to reports they intend to seek outside contractors for veterinarian services and routine animal care instead of hiring more local government employees for those roles. Those would both be good decisions. They should further investigate working with other animal welfare groups and private veterinarians to replace the Humane Society before the city buys its own facility.

Other municipalities, such as Independence and Blue Springs, have long used nonprofit organizations to provide animal-shelter services. Nonprofit organizations can take advantage of private fundraising, volunteer labor, specialized expertise, and community involvement. Those are advantages that government agencies cannot always replicate.

Columbia’s decision to purchase the building raises serious financial questions, even if it uses contractors as much as possible for daily operations. City officials have suggested that purchasing the facility would reach a break-even point financially after approximately 30 years compared with the Humane Society’s original funding request. But such calculations are only as good as their assumptions. What will staffing cost? What about maintenance, insurance, utilities, veterinary services, capital improvements, and employee benefits? Will the city be able to raise private donations and recruit volunteers as effectively as an established nonprofit?

These questions should be answered before taxpayers are committed to decades of municipal shelter ownership. The proper role of government is not necessarily to provide every service itself. It is to ensure that essential public services are delivered effectively and economically. I repeat that Columbia and Boone County deserve credit for sharing services here and for, apparently, seeking to contract out shelter operations. Nevertheless, the two governments should reconsider whether owning their own animal shelter is really the best use of taxpayer resources.

How Are Missouri’s School Choice Students Doing? With Collin Hitt

Susan Pendergrass talks with Collin Hitt, executive director of the PRiME Center at Saint Louis University, about the first research report on outcomes in MOScholars, Missouri’s education savings account program. Hitt discusses how many students are using the program, how its eligibility rules have changed, what the early test score data shows, what he learned from his work on Louisiana’s evaluation, and more.

Read the report

Listen on Spotify

Listen on Apple Podcasts 

Listen on SoundCloud

Episode Transcript

Susan Pendergrass (00:00)

Thanks so much for joining us, Collin Hitt of the PRiME Center at St. Louis University. You’ve been on the podcast before. We appreciate you coming back.

Collin Hitt (00:07)

Good to be back.

Susan Pendergrass (00:08)

Nice. So you know, let’s see. Missouri’s had a program for what, three, four years, four years at least, where we have six scholarship granting organizations that Missourians, individuals and companies can donate to. And those organizations give out scholarships to students with a priority on students who have disabilities and low income students, and it’s called MOScholars. It’s an education scholarship account program, just to clear that up, an ESA. And all along when the program was created, there’s always been a requirement that somebody would report on how the kids are doing. And that hasn’t happened until this year and the PRiME Center has sort of taken on that work and I’m so grateful that you have. But what if I just would like to know like what is the basic outline of this program, how many kids are using it, where are they, and what do we know about the usage of the program?

Collin Hitt (01:03)

Right, so MOScholars is an education savings account program where parents, you know, on behalf of students, can receive an education savings account from which they can pay for things like private school tuition, other educational supplies, attending a different public school district outside of their residence school district and a number of other educational supports. The revenue from that comes through two streams. One is through direct donations, for which you know Missouri donors can receive a Missouri tax credit. And increasingly a direct appropriation from the General Assembly. Nationally, it’s relatively unique in that it has those two different revenue streams. But you know, that’s where the money comes from. I think the program was created in 2021, donations started at that point, students began to enroll or rather began to go to school with support from MOScholars in the fall of 2022.

Susan Pendergrass (01:56)

Okay. So about how many kids are using?

Collin Hitt (01:58)

Right. So you know, early on you saw you know about thirteen hundred students in the program in the first year, up to three thousand by year three. That’s what our research window covers. In the year that just concluded, closer to seven thousand, and then the year that we’re talking in here, which is the 2026-27 school year, you’re looking at probably ten thousand students or more.

Susan Pendergrass (02:24)

So demand has been strong really, like once people find out about it. And also eligibility was dramatically changed a couple of years ago.

Collin Hitt (02:33)

Right. So initially the main eligibility requirements initially were, you know, sort of around geography plus income. One thing that’s been constant over time is that students with an IEP, that’s an individual education plan, special needs students, were always at the front of the line and eligible. It just where you lived has changed and expanded over time. So that’s certainly driven program enrollment growth and awareness as well.

Susan Pendergrass (02:58)

And so you have a report coming out discussing some of these things, but it’s true, right, that there’s a fairly large percentage of the students in this program are students with IEPs?

Collin Hitt (03:09)

Hundred percent. I shouldn’t say a hundred percent. That was me agreeing with you. Definitely. You know, over thirty percent of the students and MOScholars have an IEP, an even higher percentage of the students that are in our testing sample are in testing grades, have an IEP. And everybody else who’s in the program is admitted based on means testing, how much money their family has, or whether or not they have a sibling in the program. But those are the two, those are the two screens. You have a program that first in line serves students with IEP and after that, you know, students from relatively low income households.

Susan Pendergrass (03:44)

So a typical school district would have what percentage of students with an IEP? Fifteen, thirteen?

Collin Hitt (03:49)

Yeah, across the state, that’s probably right.

Susan Pendergrass (03:52)

Maybe twice as high. Why do you suppose that the take up has been so strong for families of children with IEPs?

Collin Hitt (03:57)

Well one, you know, they were first in line for eligibility. That would be one. You know, and but the second is you know, and look, parents of special needs students are always hungry for options, right? And constantly working to make sure that their kids have the supports that they get and you know, and they’re willing to do just about anything to give their kids their supports. That’s how they got the IEP in the first place. So obviously there’s a fair number of Missouri families that think that the school that they can send their kid to or the educational services that they can take advantage of through MOScholars is best for their kid.

Susan Pendergrass (04:34)

So this is the real question because I’ve been working in this space for I don’t know decades now when vouchers were very exotic and novel and controversial, they’re still controversial. And the main argument was well, a couple things, two arguments were number one, it’s just gonna cream the best students out of the program. You know what I mean? Like the best students are gonna be the ones that get the vouchers and so it’s not even fair because the most disadvantaged students will be left behind. But secondly the kids that do at these vouchers don’t do any better than they would have done in their traditional public schools. So I want you to talk about your findings, but the huge caveat that these are early and small. We can’t say definitively, but you know, to the extent that that first one doesn’t seem to be true, ’cause twice as many of the kids have IEPs and the rest of them, by definition, are from low income families. What about this second idea that they’re doing no better, maybe even worse?

Collin Hitt (05:31)

Well, you know, you know, first of all, we’ll just talk about like what the data is available there and then I’ll get to your question.

Susan Pendergrass (05:35)

Yes, please. Yeah.

Collin Hitt (05:36)

So one of the things is, you know, in terms of accountability, every student in a testing grade that’s considered grades three through ten in MOScholars is required to submit reading and/or English language arts and math results on a nationally norm-referenced test.

Susan Pendergrass (05:54)

What does that mean?

Collin Hitt (05:55)

There we go. So it isn’t the official state test that’s given within public schools, which is called the Missouri MAP test. But listeners may have had their kids take an NWEA test or an Iowa test of basic skills, something like that. You know, these are standardized tests that are out there. ACT would be an example of a high school level nationally norm-referenced test. And where norm-referenced is important, especially for our analysis, is whereas you get a test score for your student, you also get a sort of test percentile. It tells you, say if your student you know has a national percentile of 55, that means that your kid scored in the 55th percentile nationally, which is to say out of every one hundred kids, you know, your kid is scoring higher than fifty five of them and lower than forty five. You know, so the cool thing about that is that no matter what test a student is using, we can then equate it on that nationally norm-referenced scale. You know, across the program, you know, we identified, you know, somewhere between fifteen to nineteen different tests in use. Go ahead.

Susan Pendergrass (07:18)

Yeah, wow. I mean but most kids are taking a couple of them, right?

Collin Hitt (07:21)

Yeah, yeah, yeah. There’s certainly the ones that I just mentioned, you know, there certainly are those that are most popular and stand out. Iowa assessments, NWEA, anything in the ACT, battery attests, you know, you know, very, you know, pretty commonly named assessments. And again, these are assessments that are in use in schools, all across Missouri, across the country for the most part, the norm-referenced tests that we identified in the program. And so what do we see? That was your question. So, you know, in the first year of the program, or rather from the first to the third year of the program, you know, we see students language arts scores improve from the forty-sixth percentile nationally to the fifty first percentile nationally. And math, forty seventh to the forty ninth over that same period of time.

Susan Pendergrass (08:11)

So I mean, so basically what you’re saying is the students in this program, and in your case it’s about three thousand students, right, that have test scores or twenty five hundred.

Collin Hitt (08:20)

So that has increased dramatically across years. So yeah, pooled across all years. That’s about right. So in the first year the program, about six hundred and twenty-nine well exactly six hundred and twenty-nine kids had tests. You know, again, you’re only gonna have tests for students who are testing grades, which right now is grades three through ten in MOScholars. That increased to nine sixty-one in the second year, thirteen fifty-one in the third year. And by the fourth year of the program, which this will be in future reports, you’ve got 2,972 students in those same, those tested grades. And that’s just going to explode further for a couple of reasons. One, the program is growing. Second of all, at present, fully half of the students in the MOScholars program are in grades kindergarten, first, and second. So as those students age into the program, the number of students in tested grades is going to explode. And so these results could very well look different as that sample of kids changes, but we will see in future years.

Susan Pendergrass (09:21)

But what we know with the small sample is it isn’t biased towards it. We don’t have any information that it’s biased towards higher-performing kids. And when they are being norm-referenced, they’re not being norm-referenced to students with disabilities or to low-income students, right? It’s the national average number, and these kids are scoring at or just above or just below basically the average kid in the United States, which seems kind of incredible to me.

Collin Hitt (09:49)

Right. So, you know, you’re again, you know, the sample that we’re looking at, you know, is thirty to forty percent of these students have IEPs. So the typical student in MOScholars is far more likely to have a special education plan than your average student nationally. And the rest of the students in the program are admitted through means testing. These are relatively low income households in Missouri, which would then mean relatively low income households nationally. So I think a lot of people, if they had to guess, you know, knowing that about your student sample, you know, you know, would probably predict test scores that are lower than what we’re seeing. That’s certainly the case for me. I was surprised at what we saw.

Susan Pendergrass (10:34)

And I know you can’t really compare them to the average Missouri student, but certainly these kids aren’t doing worse than the average Missouri student. Would that be fair to say?

Collin Hitt (10:42)

Missouri’s official state test is not nationally norm-referenced. It’s tough to take it and say, okay, the average Missouri student scores at this part nationally, using Missouri’s official state test. But we have another test out there called NAEP, right? Most people would recognize that as the nation’s report card. Every state gives this. It’s a federally funded and administered test given every other year to fourth and eighth graders. And the typical Missouri student that takes the NAEP, and this is a representative sample. Of Missouri students scores between the 47th and the 45th percentile nationally on reading and math. So if you want to compare that number to what we’re seeing in MOScholars, you can say the typical student in MOScholars is scoring at or above, where the typical student in Missouri is scoring on NAEP. It’s a bit of a back of the map calculation, but it’s the best we can do right now.

Susan Pendergrass (11:38)

I still think that’s kind of incredible because as you know, like early results of other programs, Louisiana comes to mind, you know, they were not positive. They weren’t even average and in DC too, I think, because these programs take a little bit of time and the kids have to adjust to a new school and now they’re taking a different test. Maybe they used to take the math test, or maybe it’s their first round of testing. And normally there’s sort of this kind of you know, this period of time where everyone’s getting used to the program and warming up to it or something. But these are our earliest test scores and they look good. Were you surprised when you saw?

Collin Hitt (12:15)

Well, I was a member of the research team on Louisiana’s evaluation.

Susan Pendergrass (12:19)

Tell me what happened in Louisiana.

Collin Hitt (12:20)

Well one of the things that happened in Louisiana is the program was passed and rushed to implementation right away. And students also had to take the official state test. So there are a couple things happening there. But one of which is that schools themselves would not have had time to sort of adapt their curriculum or their teaching in any way to the state test. The whole idea of a state test is that it’s built around a curriculum that public schools are using in one way or another. And another is, you know, the schools themselves. You know, it was not ideal across the board. One, you know, sort of rushed implementation. Schools hadn’t had time to adapt their curriculum. One, the second, this wasn’t a test that they were used to giving in their particular schools. Third, the program was definitely targeted towards neediest students. Fourth, you know, there’s a possibility that some of the schools that rushed to be first in line for that program were schools themselves that had a ton of open seats. And you can infer what you will about maybe what the quality of those schools were. But again those were year one results over time.

Susan Pendergrass (13:31)

What were the results? But what were

Collin Hitt (13:33)

Now, in Louisiana, they also had an enrollment lottery. So most school choice programs of different sorts have enrollment lotteries, because mainly to be fair, right? Because folks have concerns that the programs could end up being selective. They want to make sure that everybody who applies has an equal chance at getting in. But it also creates a really cool opportunity for us as researchers and that the only thing that separates students who were admitted versus those who weren’t is random chance. We don’t yet have a design like that in Missouri. It should be very clear. But, you know, in Louisiana that was the comparison. So those kids that were admitted to the program by lottery versus those that weren’t in year one certainly scored significantly lower. Those results faded over time such that those two groups of students were performing roughly comparably in Louisiana. And you saw some suggestive evidence, although imprecisely estimated, that maybe there were even some graduation rate you know benefits over time. But again, you know, that was a program that was studied, you know, at launch and versus a mature program that had had a chance to get its feet under it.

Susan Pendergrass (14:42)

Yeah, I think sometimes with these programs, the folks who support these policies and want these programs to happen, I might just be making this up. But it seems to me that sometimes folks don’t want the students to have to take testing or to have to prove that they’re doing better than just the fact that their families want this other school is enough to say that, you know, that’s the market working and they shouldn’t have to prove that their test scores improve. And so sometimes I think there’s a little bit of a reluctance to work that into the program. But Missouri included it in the legislation right when it was passed. They have to take a nationally norm-referenced test and they gotta submit these test scores now to you guys at PRiME. And that leaves a little bit of vulnerability and exposure, but the results I think are much better than what I would have expected.

Collin Hitt (15:29)

Again, you know, you know, I would be encouraged by this. You know, people who thought that, okay, students who enroll in this program are gonna be scoring in the 90th percentile nationally right away, I suppose would be disappointed. Those who were predicting that these students are gonna be scoring far, far below the average Missouri student would have been wrong as well. You know, overall, again, like I said, you know, I was surprised at where we saw the numbers and I view it as relatively encouraging as somebody who’s, you know, you know, really hoping. To identify programs that can improve kids’ reading and math skills, whatever that program is.

Susan Pendergrass (16:06)

Yeah, I mean, from what I’ve seen, the virtual programs in Missouri, MOCAP, what they’re called, their achievement results are not very good, honestly. And again, we’re talking about kids who, for any number of reasons, the school that they’re assigned to, their traditional public school, isn’t a fit. It doesn’t work well. So they’re looking for an option. So some parents are choosing the virtual option, the MOCAP option. If you live near St. Louis or Kansas City, you can choose a charter school if you’re in the right district. And those kids generally do better than they would have done if they stayed in a traditional public school. And now we’ve got this new third option for Missouri families, which is MOScholars, right? So we at the Show-Me Institute are just pressing for every family to have at least two or three high-quality options. I don’t, whatever they are. I want people, if they’re like, my child’s being bullied, the teachers aren’t getting along with my child, whatever the reason is, it’s too big, it’s too small, I don’t really care. I need another option, I want them to have it. But we need to look at how these programs are designed and how they’re doing, and it seems to me like MOScholars might have a good design and it might have some pretty promising results for participants.

Collin Hitt (17:15)

Well, on that front as well, other data that we’ve looked at is parent satisfaction data. The law not only has testing requirements, it also requires that the state treasurer’s office who oversees this program conduct a parent satisfaction survey and the parents that responded to that survey were overwhelmingly satisfied with the program and one of the questions that’s asked is would you recommend this program to somebody else and again that was, you know, an overwhelming yes

Susan Pendergrass (17:45)

And the kids, if you know, the students with IEPs, are they attending schools that are designed for students with IEPs? Because I think another potential I’m thinking like, what are the reasons for all these? I do think program design, having that intermediary organization that gives out the scholarships that has a vested interest in having the program work, right? So they’re trying to match families to schools that are a good match for them. I think that that might be helpful. But also, you know, Missouri’s got five hundred and fifty odd school districts. We have a lot of tiny school districts. And if your child is identified, especially early as having a disability, let’s say they are hearing impaired, right? You know this right after they’re born. You know they’re hearing impaired. You’re going to be looking for the best program to give your child a full, robust education. And challenge them and everything. And not every school district out in the middle of Missouri that’s got a hundred kids is equipped to have a hearing impaired child, right? So I could see this being a much more successful program given the structure of public education in Missouri, because all these small districts that have to be everything to everyone and they just can’t be.

Collin Hitt (18:53)

Yeah. So, you know, one thing about your kind of questions in order there is there are some schools that are sort of participating in the program that are, you know, specially geared towards special needs kids. But I think, you know, you know, by and large the students with IEPs and MOScholars are spread over a wide variety of schools, some specialized schools like what you’re talking about, but otherwise traditional brick and mortar private schools. There’s also family-paced education students, otherwise, you know, homeschool or micro school students, you know, as well. But I would say this, you know, as well, that for a parent, for a family that is in this program that has a student with an IEP that is not in a traditional public school through the program, they are still entitled to the same services that a private or non-public school student is entitled to who has an IEP. They’re no different in this case than they are a straight up tuition paying parent at the school that they’re at. They’re getting tuition assistance, but they’re tuition paying parent. But that doesn’t change that their child is still legally and frankly morally entitled to you know federally funded special education services in their area through their local school district.

Susan Pendergrass (20:08)

Yeah, and certainly the point of this program isn’t to save money, but these kids are getting six thousand on average, but perhaps students with IEPs are getting more. I think they are eligible for higher dollar amounts. But it still seems to me it would be a small fraction of what is spent on those children in a traditional public school, certainly lower than six thousand dollars. So for folks, you know, right now the legislature’s put sixty million dollars towards this. I suspect that the demand in Missouri easily could justify double that. But I’m concerned more about people are saying that Missourians are getting ripped off by this program and yet the families are taking much less money and the kids are doing average or better than average. To me it feels like a very productive, efficient program.

Collin Hitt (20:59)

Well, I mean, public spending, be it through a tax expenditure or through a direct appropriation on this program, is almost certainly less per pupil than what you would see if these students were attending a public school. And then as for the expense associated with IEPs, I think it’s important to point out, especially as is, you know, we as a country, you know, we as a planet are getting better at spotting, say, for example, kids with autism or kids on the autism spectrum. Very often what these kids need is not a whole host of really expensive services. They need accommodations, they need an inclusive environment. They need a school that understands their needs and is just willing to be flexible to give them what they want. And so for these students, you know, the resources are there if they can find an environment like that through this program.

Susan Pendergrass (21:57)

Yeah, which is great. And I know like Arizona’s got a similar sort of similar ESA program, all publicly funded, and they have over a hundred thousand kids in theirs. But there are, as you mentioned, schools that are specifically focused on children with autism and you know they have like better soundproofing and they have like less distraction. I mean there are ways, not necessarily expensive, to arrange the environment in a way that’s more advantageous. Do you have any speculation as to what you would see as the maximum take up of this program in Missouri? Speculating.

Collin Hitt (22:34)

And we don’t know. Yeah, it’s speculating. I believe it was just announced that there are ten thousand students approved for the upcoming year and a few thousand more on a wait list. And that’s even as you know, you know, parents can continue to sign up. Arizona’s a similarly sized state. There are a hundred thousand students in Arizona’s program. Make of that what you will.

Susan Pendergrass (23:00)

I mean, Texas, they announced a billion dollar program for a hundred thousand kids and they had filled all the spots. Like I mean, when these programs become available, and certainly there are a few states that are universally eligible, universally paid for, like Florida, you know, it’s not every kid. I think it maxes out at ten percent, twenty percent, but you know, for those ten or twenty percent, it’s an incredible opportunity to fix something that’s going wrong. So to me it feels worth it. But that’s, you know.

Collin Hitt (23:31)

Well, I think the real numbers to look at, Susan, are not just what percentage of kids in the state of Missouri are enrolled in this program right now. The better way to think about it, and we’ll know this over time, is what percentage of kids in the state of Missouri will ever be served by this program? Some of the students who are in MOScholars now will move back into the public school system, you know, if that’s the better option for them. Some of the students who are presently in the public school system will move into MOScholars. So then the percentage of students who are served by a program like this is over time, is always going to be higher than that single point in time. Do that math again then with families, right? You know, almost every family I know, you know, that’s got multiple kids in, say, St. Louis, where we’re located, the St. Louis University has got their kids spread across, you know, multiple sectors, right? Different kids have different needs at different ages, you know, there’s different opportunities available. So, you know, a higher percentage of families will probably experience or take advantage of this program at some point in time.

Susan Pendergrass (24:36)

Yeah, it just like to me, I feel like it’s got a good design. We seem to have some evidence of that. We seem to have some evidence that the kids are doing well. And we seem to have some evidence that it’s costing taxpayers less than these kids cost in their traditional public school district. And I really would hope that Missouri legislators realize what a great program we have and that they do whatever they need to do to keep it going. ‘Cause I mean it’s already been sued. There’s already, you know the wolves are at the door to try to kill this program and now we’ve got ten thousand Missouri children. I mean, we’re just growing the number of families, like you said, that have had any contact with it and you know, to kill it or to try to limit it in any way I just think would be such a mistake.

Collin Hitt (25:21)

Well, you know, one of the things that’s interesting, you talk about demand and all of that, you know, another piece that we’ve done in partnership with the State Treasurer’s Office again, who runs this program in Missouri, is look at where students are located by school district, by legislative district. And you can see as geographic restrictions have been lifted on the program all over time, you just see the map of Missouri really fill up as to the reach of the program, which is just a really interesting thing to watch.

Susan Pendergrass (25:48)

I think it’s cool. I haven’t seen the Missouri data. I do recall seeing the Iowa data the first year of their program and they had at least one scholarship student in every county. You know what I mean? It’s just like there is no reason to say that rural families don’t want this or that urban families don’t want this or families in southeast Missouri don’t want this. It is not that you know, it’s like you said, it’s a kid by kid thing.

Collin Hitt (26:08)

Right. Well, if that’s what the data showed, we’d be obligated to say so. But we’re seeing otherwise. You know, and I think the last time I was on your show we were talking about the percentage of kids in Missouri who were homeschooling. And it went from somewhere around thirty thousand pre pandemic to 60,000, 60,000 students post-pandemic, out of 1 million total kids in Missouri, and has stayed there over time. Some percentage of that growth, some percentage of that extra 30,000 kids, are actually in micro schools or cottage schools or co-ops or whatever you want to call them. And you’re gonna be able to learn more about that through the data that comes through MOScholars, as well as, you know, as we see, who the providers are that are attached to the program. And that’s part of the mechanism of action as well. You know, the idea behind a program, like MOScholars, is one, perhaps there is a setting out there that is a better fit for your kid right now. That’s one idea of how this is gonna work. Another would be it creates the opportunity for new actors to enter. For folks that have new ideas of how to educate kids or new ideas for a school, even if it’s a micro school or something like that, suddenly they have a way for the kids that they hope to serve to be able to afford to go to something like that. So you know, I expect that what you’re gonna see over time with something like MOScholars is a sort of catalyst for this sort of social entrepreneurship if you will you know these folks that are starting their own or expanding their own organizations to serve kids and I think in rural areas a lot of that is going to be in this micro schooling space

Susan Pendergrass (27:49)

Yeah, we’ve seen that in Arizona, where suppliers, I mean, people who specialize in dyslexia or, you know, woodcrafters or baking schools, whatever like these suppliers are like, the families want the services and the suppliers wanna provide them to the families. And now you have this great overlap on the demand side and supply side, which is cool.

Collin Hitt (28:12)

Yeah, so there’s a really interesting school like in Columbia, for example, Columbia, Missouri, that you know, was a tutoring program, a reading intensive tutoring program into the pandemic. And then families started to ask, would you consider a sort of full-time option? And started out with a handful of kids. Now is a full K through twelve school. At any particular grade, you would certainly call it a micro school. And you know, a large percentage of those kids are now able to participate in MOScholars. So it’s an example of an organization that was serving kids already that sort of became a school. And now is able to serve more kids than it otherwise would thanks to a program like MOScholars. And that’s part of the theory of action behind a program like this, is that it sort of spurs innovation or pulls other folks sort of off the sideline and into the full with new ideas and you know new environments.

Susan Pendergrass (29:09)

That’s awesome. So you guys will continue to take the test score data and all the other data that are collected, analyze it, organize it for those of us who wanna find out more and then assemble it into reports. You’re gonna do this every year.

Collin Hitt (29:24)

Yeah, no, wait, yes. The report that we’re discussing is the first in what now will be annual reports where the research and data partner for the MOScholars program for the state of Missouri through 2029 at least.

Susan Pendergrass (29:36)

That’s awesome. And where can we where can listeners find these reports if they want to read them?

Collin Hitt (29:40)

Well, you can certainly find them at primecenter.org. Or if you so desire, you can go to the State Treasurer’s MOScholars website as well.

Susan Pendergrass (29:47)

Awesome. Well thanks so much, Collin, for coming back. I appreciate it. Well, I’m sure we’ll have you back again. Thanks so much.

Collin Hitt (29:50)

Always a pleasure, Susan. Thank you much.

Produced by Show-Me Opportunity

What to Know About Amendment 6 in Missouri

On Tuesday, November 3, Missouri voters will decide on Amendment 6. Below you’ll find a one-pager and a frequently asked questions document on the measure.

Amendment 6 One-Pager

Download the One-Pager

Your browser can’t display this document here.

Open the One-Pager

Amendment 6 FAQs

Download the FAQs

Your browser can’t display this document here.

Open the FAQs

Getting it Right on SNAP

Missouri could face millions in new food stamp costs by this time next year if the state doesn’t get its act together. As I’ve written previously, funding rules for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) were changed in 2025, requiring states with payment error rates of 6% or higher to begin covering a share of benefit costs starting in October 2027. While recent reports suggest Missouri may be making progress, several neighboring states have already demonstrated that substantially better performance is possible.

According to the latest official data from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Missouri’s SNAP payment error rate was 8.67% in fiscal year (FY) 2025, which is very high, but still below the national average of 10.62%. Payment errors include overpayments and underpayments resulting from mistakes in determining eligibility or calculating benefits. Although they are not necessarily evidence of fraud, these errors mean households receive more or less assistance than they are entitled to receive.

Source: USDA, FY 2025 SNAP Payment Error Rates

As the table shows, overpayments account for most SNAP payment errors (meaning more is being paid than should be), including nearly 95% of Missouri’s total error rate. And while Missouri compares favorably with five of its eight neighboring states, Kentucky, Iowa, and Nebraska have already achieved rates below the prescribed 6% threshold.

A high error rate could prove extremely costly for Missouri. Based on FY 2025 error rates, Missouri could be responsible for approximately $156 million in additional program benefit costs next year. Reducing the error rate below 8% would cut that amount in half, while getting the error rate below 6% would eliminate the additional costs altogether.

As I wrote recently, Missouri has already begun taking steps to improve payment accuracy, including new documentation requirements to verify eligibility. Preliminary figures reported by the Missouri Department of Social Services also suggest the state’s FY 2026 error rate may have fallen to approximately 5.9%. If that’s true, Missouri could avoid additional benefit costs in the first year, when states can use the lower of their FY 2025 or FY 2026 rates.

It is important to keep in mind that while Missouri’s reported improvement is encouraging, the figures are not yet official, and the state will need to maintain that accuracy to avoid costs in subsequent years. With neighboring states already demonstrating that lower error rates are achievable, Missouri should continue looking for ways to improve payment accuracy, ensure eligible households receive the correct benefits, and protect taxpayers from unnecessary expenses.

Empty Diplomas

Over at The 74, John Arnold penned an op-ed reminding us that getting more students to graduate from high school is not necessarily a good thing. It depends on how we do it. He writes: “If boosting graduation is the goal, one way to get there is to lower standards.”

High school graduation rates are up across the United States, but there is mounting evidence that we are achieving these gains by lowering standards. Arnold points to international assessment data showing that U.S. students are performing worse academically, even as more of them graduate.

As an example of misguided policy Arnold turns to New York, which recently announced it would eliminate the requirement that students pass Regents exams to graduate. This is a clear policy choice aimed at producing more diplomas at the expense of credibility. Arnold writes:

Shielding students from high standards is not compassionate; it simply delays the consequences. It also signals to students that you don’t have to do the work to still graduate. That message is particularly dangerous: Why try if it isn’t going to matter? The result: more students unprepared for what comes next.

Missouri doesn’t have a high school exit exam, so we’re already operating in a system where academic standards are relatively easy to circumvent. Last year, I wrote about Missouri’s rising graduation rates. The statewide graduation rate increased from 76 percent in 2001 to 85 percent in 2010, and to almost 90 percent by 2023.

During the first decade of the 21st century, our rising graduation rates were accompanied by academic gains. But since then, the trends have diverged. Graduation rates continued to rise even as student achievement began to decline. Missouri’s scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress started falling before the pandemic, and the decline accelerated when the pandemic hit. The average ACT score in Missouri was 21.5 in the early 2010s; by 2023, it had fallen below 20 for the first time in recent history.

In other words, Missouri is awarding more high school diplomas even as the academic skills of its students deteriorate. We should be deeply concerned about what these diplomas actually represent.

The problem is that we have confused getting students through school with educating them. Graduation rates are easy to measure, and rising graduation rates make schools and policymakers look successful. But a diploma is supposed to certify that a student has acquired the knowledge and skills needed to succeed in adult life. When we award diplomas to students who lack those skills, we aren’t helping them. We’re simply concealing the problem until they leave school.

Arnold is right that lowering standards is no kindness to students. The purpose of our education system is not to produce diplomas. It is to produce educated young adults who are prepared for what comes next. A diploma should be evidence that we’ve accomplished that goal, not a substitute for accomplishing it.

Support Us

The work of the Show-Me Institute would not be possible without the generous support of people who are inspired by the vision of liberty and free enterprise. We hope you will join our efforts and become a Show-Me Institute sponsor.

Donate
Man on Horse Charging