Senate Removes $300 Million in Warehouse Construction Tax Credits From Aerotropolis Bill

Missouri Sen. Rob Mayer (R-Dist. 25) announced today that $300 million in tax credits for the construction of warehouses had been removed from the Aerotropolis legislation, part of a contentious economic development bill that the Missouri Legislature is considering in a special session.

Regular Show-Me Daily readers are, I am sure, nearly sick of hearing about Patrick Ishmael’s and my questions regarding that $300 million.

We wondered: Why was the state considering subsidizing warehouse construction in the St. Louis area if there was more than 18 million square feet in vacant warehouse space already available? Why did versions of the legislation give the mayor of St. Louis City and area county executives the power to restrict who could receive hundreds of millions in tax benefits? Why were the construction tax credits limited to individuals and companies who owned more than 100 acres of land? Where was a substantive cost-benefit analysis?

We would have stopped asking those questions if someone had provided substantive answers. And yet, there really were none.

It is brazen to ask for $300 million, in the public or private sector, without substantive evidence that the money is necessary and would be put to good, productive use. As such, the removal of warehouse and facility construction tax credits from the legislation is good news for Missouri taxpayers.

But, things could easily change. There is a chance that the $300 million could be reinserted at the last moment. CBS reports that the Missouri House may attempt to re-insert construction tax credits in the legislation and “ram the bill through the Senate.”

So, perhaps, this may be more about politics than good policy. I hope that isn’t the case.

Hot New Argument for Tax Breaks in Kansas City: Abate My Taxes, Or I Just Might Build a QuikTrip

Taxpayer-subsidized apartments or $1 buffalo chicken hot dogs? How will I ever decide? (Emphasis mine.)

Read what David Martin wrote in The Pitch:

The project, which has neighborhood support, sounds worthwhile. But there’s a catch. The public has to provide assistance. The developer is asking for a tax break worth $2.76 million.

The Kansas City City Council will be told that the project won’t work without the incentives. Yes, West 39th Street is vibrant with restaurants. Across the state line, the University of Kansas Hospital is expanding.

The developer concedes that the failed Qdoba sits on a valuable piece of land. But here’s where the proposal begins to look like blackmail.

“Sure, it’s an attractive piece of property for development for lots of different uses,” Aaron March, an attorney working for Price Development, tells The Pitch. “But if we were just in it for the money, we would sell it to McDonald’s or QuikTrip. But we’re not.”

[…]

So what will you have, Kansas City, a spiffy new apartment building or a McFlurry? “If you’d rather have a convenience store or a gas station or a fast-food restaurant,” March says, “then don’t give the incentives.”

This is the view from the property’s doorstep.


View Larger Map

It takes real je ne sais pas quoi to go to the government, concede that your property’s valuable, and then claim that if you don’t get a tax abatement, your only option would be to build a gas station or a fast food joint. That may be business as usual these days when it comes to the private sector’s interactions with the government, but it’s bad business, and bad policy.

An Open Letter to Jamie Allman and 97.1

Jamie,

I hope all is well in “common sense radio” land. I heard you had John Beck, your senior vice-president, on with you this morning, and that you or he gave us a mention. I appreciate that, but I continue to be mystified that you and/or Mr. Beck won’t allow one of our policy analysts on your program to discuss the Aerotropolis proposal.

We here at the Show-Me Institute have studied and written about this bill for months. To simply claim, as I’m told Mr. Beck did, that we are against all tax credits is shallow, at best, and in this case, completely misses the point. The fact, as we have pointed out in numerous op-eds, papers, blog posts, videos and radio and TV interviews, is that Aerotropolis remains a massive tax credit giveaway program that may well leave Missouri taxpayers picking up the tab.

Mr. Beck, who is also a board member of the RCGA, clearly doesn’t see it the way we do. That’s fine, but isn’t this topic important enough that your listeners deserve to hear both sides of the debate? I repeat what has become a long-standing offer to have one of our policy analysts come on your program to talk about Aerotropolis.

I await your call.

Best,

Rick Edlund
Communications Director
Show-Me Institute
314-454-0647

Property Taxes in Missouri: Police, Fire, Municipal Bands?

In this comprehensive look at property taxation in Missouri, Show-Me Institute Policy Analyst David Stokes highlights examples of all the things supported by property taxes. Also included is a look at what sorts of things work well when funded by property taxes and what sorts of things don’t.

 

Read the full policy study here.

Read the related case study here.

Property Taxes in Missouri: Are You Paying for a Municipal Band?

In this short video, Show-Me Institute Policy Analyst David Stokes gives an overview of a few things funded by property taxes. He also offers a prescription for which sorts of things work best when funded by property taxation, and which sorts of things don’t.

 

Read the full policy study here.

Read the related case study here.

See the full video discussing examples of all kinds of property taxes here.

Support Us

The work of the Show-Me Institute would not be possible without the generous support of people who are inspired by the vision of liberty and free enterprise. We hope you will join our efforts and become a Show-Me Institute sponsor.

Donate
Man on Horse Charging