Hospital Prices Still Too Hard to Find

Hospitals may be getting better at following federal price transparency rules, but are patients getting any closer to knowing what their care will cost? A new report suggests there’s still a significant gap between complying with the rules and providing prices patients can actually use.

PatientRightsAdvocate.org (PRA) reviewed 2,000 hospitals and found that 49.4% complied with federal transparency requirements, up from just 21.1% in its previous report. That’s substantial progress, but

PRA found that only 18% of hospitals posted what it calls “dollar-and-cents prices,” meaning an actual amount rather than a percentage or formula, for at least half of the items and services in their pricing files. Just 10% of hospitals were both fully compliant with federal requirements and met PRA’s standard for sufficient dollar-and-cents prices.

How can a hospital comply without posting an actual price? Federal rules allow hospitals to use percentages or formulas when a negotiated price cannot be expressed as a dollar amount in advance. PRA gives the example of a hospital that listed the negotiated price for an uncomplicated childbirth as 44.4% of its total billed charges. Although the file included historical payment amounts, the patient still could not determine what the birth would cost without knowing what charges would be included in the total.

The problem isn’t limited to hospitals outside Missouri. None of the eight Missouri SSM Health hospitals reviewed by PRA met its standard for sufficient dollar-and-cents pricing. Six were specifically cited because their formulas did not provide enough information for patients to determine an actual price.

Fortunately, the federal government has already taken steps to address these shortcomings. Updated requirements took effect in January, with enforcement beginning in April, requiring hospitals that use percentages or formulas to also report historical payment amounts in dollars. While those figures provide patients with more useful information, they still may not reveal what a particular service will cost. Because PRA reviewed hospital pricing files shortly after enforcement began, its findings do not tell us how hospitals have responded since then.

As I recently wrote, Missouri also enacted a new law restricting debt collection by hospitals that materially violate federal price transparency requirements. However, the law depends on federal action; the federal government can either levy a financial penalty or give official notification that a hospital failed to correct material deficiencies. None of the eight SSM hospitals appear on the federal penalty list, although that alone does not establish whether Missouri’s restrictions would apply.

The progress documented in PRA’s report is encouraging, but there is still a long way to go. Hospitals should provide prices patients can understand and compare before receiving care, and those that fail to meet federal requirements should face meaningful consequences. After nearly six years of federal price transparency requirements, patients shouldn’t still have to guess what their care will cost.

Discovery in Reading

I was recently spending time with friends who were playing the popular video game Mortal Kombat. While watching, I became intrigued and wanted to play.

I eagerly grabbed a controller and began to play, with no tutorial or instruction. Soon, my fascination with the game decreased as I continued losing (badly), and I declared, “Wow, I am horrible at this.” However, I eventually stopped ramming my head against a wall and at the urging of my friends, agreed to complete a brief tutorial. It clicked. I returned to the game and I was then able to discover different intricacies on my own. I was better equipped and ready for self-discovery.

You will have to forgive my long analogy, but I believe it is relevant. Far too often in the education sector, phonics and science of reading instruction are treated as a draconian, fun-killing endeavor that makes students never want to touch a book again.

But what about people like me, as I was repeatedly failing at Mortal Kombat, and just about to give up altogether? Students need to be taught skills directly, even if it’s “not fun.” A period of structured instruction and deliberate practice is far better than an indefinite period of feeling like a failure and wanting to avoid something altogether (like I have with roller skating ever since middle school. One day I’ll let someone teach me!).

Some students may need only a tiny bit of instruction before discovering much on their own. We often describe these students as “naturals.” But generally, direct instruction is tremendously valuable.

Education researcher Chad Aldeman puts it like this:

Students often need a dose of direct instruction to gain knowledge about a topic before they can write about, analyze, compare, or think critically. They need a solid base of knowledge to exercise those skills, and some amount of carefully constructed direct instruction can often help them get there.

Reading is an exciting subject, and there is so much joy in discovery through reading. Yet those who have not been taught properly can let discouragement keep them from discovering. That’s why early literacy reform is imperative: We need more Missouri students to become confident, capable readers.

Literacy reform failed to pass last year, but my colleagues and I will continue to push for reforms based on our early literacy model policy during the upcoming legislative session. Hopefully, Missouri lawmakers will finally give our children the support they need.

The Best Ideas for Fixing U.S. Schools, Part 2

In September, The New York Times published 30 Ideas for Fixing U.S. Schools, Ranked by Experts. I was among the 37 experts surveyed about the effectiveness and cost of various reforms. In an earlier post I discussed two ideas where I agree with the consensus. Here I’ll talk about one where I disagree: the value of school vouchers.

Vouchers allow public education funding to follow students to private schools. The key distinction from our current system is not who pays—the government funds education either way—but who provides the service. Must it be a government-run school, or can it be a private provider?

The panel ranked vouchers among the least effective and most expensive ideas. I see things differently.

Why? I believe one reason is that we are imagining different policies. Are we considering a small program with limited eligibility and few participating schools, or a mature system with a thick competitive market? Would schools be required to administer tests and report results so families could assess academic quality?

I envisioned a mature system with a robust private-school market and modest testing requirements. I believe such a system could lower costs, with modest improvements in student outcomes.

On the cost side, other experts may have been thinking of research showing that many voucher recipients would have attended private schools anyway. These students add to government spending without generating any savings. But this is unsurprising in smaller programs. Families already using private schools can immediately benefit from a new subsidy, while public-school families have relatively few new options. However, as programs expand, new schools can enter and existing schools can grow, giving more public-school families meaningful choices. Over time, I would expect a growing share of voucher recipients to come from public schools, creating opportunities for substantial cost savings.

In terms of improving academic outcomes, I believe vouchers can help, but they are no panacea. Families often prioritize other factors (e.g., safety, religion, sports) over academics, limiting potential academic gains. Moreover, even families who value achievement may struggle to identify effective schools. This is why I favor testing requirements, which can give parents information about academics, despite being generally wary of overregulation by the government.

Research based on short-term experiments and small-scale voucher programs cannot capture the full benefits of competition. This research can tell us how existing programs perform, but not what an established, competitive education market could achieve. Competition among private providers has improved quality and lowered costs throughout the economy. Why should education be different?

Kansas City’s Pet Project a Cautionary Tail for Columbia

My colleague David Stokes recently weighed in on Columbia and Boone County’s decision to spend $995,000 on a building for a joint animal shelter. City officials say the purchase will break even in about 30 years compared with cost of the Humane Society’s funding request. As Stokes notes, such calculations are only as good as their assumptions.

Unfortunately, Kansas City offers us an example of how such things can become a dog’s breakfast. And Stokes has been there at every turn.

In 2017, Kansas City voters approved a general obligation bond that included money for a new animal shelter. It passed with 67% of the vote. The project was sold as a public–private partnership: The Swope Park campus would cost $26 million, with $18 million from the bonds and $8 million raised privately. Another private campaign, “Raise the Woof,” hoped to raise another $5 million for an endowment. The city would own the building, and the nonprofit KC Pet Project would run it, in an arrangement similar to the Kansas City Zoo or Starlight Theatre.

At the time, Stokes welcomed the arrangement as a win for privatization, and he wasn’t alone. The city council included what seemed like a safeguard. Its $18 million was contingent on KC Pet Project raising $5 million. At the time, Councilwoman Jolie Justus said the campaign had already reached $3.8 million. Finance Chair Scott Wagner estimated that once the new shelter opened, the city’s annual cost of running it would rise from the $1.4 million it was spending on the old one to about $3.8 million—the only prediction in this mess that turned out to be correct. That is exactly what the city now pays under its operating contract.

Most of the construction money came through. When the campus opened in January 2020, private donors had committed more than $5 million in cash and almost $5 million in pro-bono services. The separate $5 million Raise the Woof endowment, meant to help with operating costs, is another story. There is no indication it was ever raised—the only endowment the city now mentions covers building maintenance.

What happened to private giving after the ribbon cutting is clearer. The city did not contract with KC Pet Project directly. It contracted with a separate nonprofit, the Kansas City Campus for Animal Care, for up to $3.8 million a year, on a term running to 2029 with an automatic ten-year renewal. That group, which FOX4 describes as KC Pet Project’s fundraising arm, subcontracted operations to KC Pet Project. According to its IRS filings, the Campus for Animal Care reported $4.1 million in contributions in 2018. By 2022, that had fallen to under $8,000. In 2024, it was $40. In those years, nearly all of its revenue was program service revenue, which appears to be the city contract passing through to the operator.

KC Pet Project still raises private money. But in 2024 it reported $6.1 million in government grants out of $10.4 million in total revenue, a figure that included its animal control contract. That means nearly six of every 10 dollars came from taxpayers. KC Pet Project took over animal control in 2020 after the city council overrode its own evaluation committee, which had unanimously rejected the proposal. Citations fell by 46%, complaints grew, and the city took the service back in 2025. Stokes again raised concerns about those operations. That failure was in animal control, not sheltering, but it shows how readily the council kept expanding the arrangement.

The partnership has since gone to the dogs. In February 2025, the Campus for Animal Care ended its contract and recommended the city take over the shelter. Instead, the city decided to pay KC Pet Project $3.8 million a year directly. In August, KC Pet Project’s former chief financial officer and a former board member told FOX4 that cash reserves fell from $2.66 million in May 2025 to $1.14 million that October, and to $175,000 by this spring. Contributions were running 54% under budget. A KC Pet Project spokesperson attributed the decline to rising operating costs. In September, KC Pet Project asked the city for an independent audit after finding “concerning discrepancies” in its historical financial records.

Stokes is right that contracting out is generally better than government administration, and that nonprofits can bring donors and volunteers that a city agency cannot. Even at equal cost, a contract spares the city long-term pension and healthcare obligations. But that was not the pitch. Voters were promised that private money would carry part of the load, and then the private money stopped. Kansas City’s experience adds a caution: Private enthusiasm peaks at the groundbreaking, but operating costs never end. Once a city owns the building, the risk falls on taxpayers. If Columbia and Boone County proceed, they should count only cash in hand toward any private match, write operating commitments into the contract with public reporting, and avoid automatic multi-year renewals.

Kansas City voters thought they were funding another public–private partnership. What they got was a building and a permanent line in the city budget. Columbia should be clear about which one it is buying.

Breaking Down Missouri’s Teacher Shortage

A version of the following commentary appeared in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.

News coverage concerning the teacher shortage in Missouri is evergreen and typically follows a familiar script: We have a teacher shortage because teaching is hard and teacher salaries in Missouri are among the lowest in the nation.

But what if that isn’t exactly the story?

The state has over 4,000 more full-time-equivalent (FTE) teachers than it had during the 2011–12 school year, but there are 30,000 fewer students now than there were then. Rather than a widespread shortage of teachers, there appear to be specific deficiencies in high-need subject areas and schools—a real problem, but one that requires a different policy approach than if the teacher shortage was widespread.

In St. Louis, Riverview Gardens is one of these high-need districts having difficulty filling teacher positions. Between 2018 and 2022, Riverview Gardens reported that 35 percent of its 100+ FTE teaching vacancies were left unfilled. Normandy Schools Collaborative had similar difficulties, with about 30 percent of its vacant positions being left unfilled. The vacancy rate at Jennings was about 14 percent and at Hazelwood it was about 6 percent. St. Louis Public Schools did not report data. The rest of the school districts in the region faced little to no difficulty finding teachers. In fact, 24 other districts in the region reported that they filled all of their vacancies.

More flexibility with regard to teacher pay and development could help alleviate shortage pressure in Riverview Gardens and other districts facing trouble. More specifically, there are two policy solutions Missouri ought to consider.

The first is targeted pay incentives to attract high-quality teachers to schools with the most severe challenges. This is a strategy used in other fields that face similar problems (e.g., it is used in healthcare to draw providers to high-need hospitals).

Of course, identifying high-quality teachers requires an evaluation system that meaningfully and accurately differentiates teacher performance. We lack such a system in Missouri, making it difficult to implement this kind of reform. But other states have such systems Missouri could imitate, including the Tennessee Educator Accelerator Model (TEAM).

Attracting excellent teachers to these schools with pay incentives could help solve several problems. It could fill their vacancies, improve student performance, and provide teachers with an in-classroom pathway to higher pay. For many teachers, the only promotion pathway is into administration. Teachers who excel in the classroom and want to remain there should have other advancement options.

Riverview Gardens and Normandy Schools could be an ideal match for a targeted pay-incentive program. In the period covered by the analysis, these districts had some of the highest percentages of low-income students in the state and were two of the lowest performing districts academically.

Targeted pay incentives have been tried elsewhere. When the Dallas (Texas) Independent School District offered sizable financial incentives to teachers who transferred to high-need elementary schools through its ACE program, there was immediate, significant, and durable improvement in student achievement.

A second policy option would be to ease the pathway for qualified professionals in other fields to switch into teaching careers. This would be particularly useful for filling open positions in hard-to-staff subject areas such as industrial technology or physics. Teachers in these fields are not developed in large numbers by traditional teacher-preparation programs.

Missouri does not appear to be facing a widespread teacher shortage. It has some areas of shortage, but also some areas of abundance. An effective policy response will involve focused solutions like targeted pay incentives and easing the pathway into teaching for career-switchers rather than sweeping measures.

Brace Yourselves for School and District Letter Grades

States across the country, including Missouri, are beginning to release annual school accountability report cards with letter grades, reigniting debates over how to evaluate school quality. Yet, before the first set of grades has even been released, Missouri superintendents are calling them incomplete pictures, potentially flawed, and redundant.

In Arizona, the department of education recently released its 2026 school letter grades, revealing that the share of high schools receiving a D or F surged from 1.8 percent to 8 percent. Administrator groups immediately lobbied the state board to freeze grading thresholds, arguing that honest lower grades would “confuse parents.”

This administrative resistance highlights a critical accountability challenge Show-Me Institute researchers have mentioned many times before, which is the pressure public school systems often face to dilute grading standards. As Missouri prepares to roll out official A–F letter grades for public schools under Governor Kehoe’s executive order, it will face the true test of an accountability system—withstanding political pushback.

Adults inside the education bureaucracy have powerful incentives to lobby for inflated ratings. High grades shield administrators from scrutiny and allow failing schools to avoid uncomfortable reforms. Yet when states capitulate by lowering cut scores or introducing subjective surveys about the “climate” of schools, report cards cease to serve their primary purpose of informing parents and identifying struggling schools in need of intervention. To its credit, Missouri’s school and district grading system has an automatic ratchet mechanism that raises performance thresholds if 65 percent of schools earn an A or B. Indiana and Florida have similar mechanisms.

Acknowledging low performance requires institutional courage. An A–F letter grade is not an indictment of teachers. Rather, it is meant to be a clear diagnostic tool. Without unvarnished transparency, underperforming schools cannot improve. To date, Missouri’s accountability system for districts has been meaningless. More than 99 percent of districts are fully accredited. As Missouri finalizes its school grading framework, state leaders must follow the lessons of states like Arizona and Florida and resist administrative pressure to lower the bar. It’s time to give parents the clear, honest information they deserve.

Missouri’s New Price Transparency Law

After years of waiting, Missouri patients have a new protection against hospitals that fail to disclose their prices. A new law took effect in August, restricting debt collection practices by hospitals found to be “materially out of compliance” with federal price transparency requirements. The provision represents a positive step toward making healthcare prices more transparent, although questions remain about its enforcement.

I’ve been regularly writing about the new federal hospital price transparency rules since they took effect in 2021. The rules require hospitals to publicly disclose their prices, including negotiated insurance rates, so patients can compare costs before receiving care. Noncompliant hospitals can face warnings, corrective action plans, and financial penalties.

Unfortunately, as I’ve also written about, hospitals have been slow to disclose their prices, and the federal government has been reluctant to penalize noncompliance. It should go without saying that patients should have an opportunity to know what their care will cost before receiving it. And it only makes sense for hospitals that refuse to disclose their prices to not be allowed to use debt collection practices. Since 2022, my colleagues and I have recommended that Missouri establish its own price transparency requirements and penalties, including prohibiting debt collection.

While Missouri’s new law sounds similar to this recommendation, there is an important difference. The state’s new prohibition on debt collection is tied to the current federal rule and depends on federal enforcement. This means that federal regulators must either assess a financial penalty or officially determine that a hospital failed to correct material deficiencies before Missouri’s prohibition can take effect.

According to the Government Accountability Office, federal regulators initiated 1,287 enforcement actions between 2021 and 2023, but only 14 resulted in financial penalties. As of October 2026, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services had publicly listed financial penalties against just 28 hospitals nationwide. Although a penalty is not the only action that can trigger Missouri’s law, the small number illustrates the limitations of relying on federal enforcement.

There is some optimism that federal enforcement could become more aggressive. The Trump administration has renewed its emphasis on hospital price transparency, with stronger disclosure requirements that took effect in January, and enforcement beginning in April. These changes are intended to address problems with hospitals publishing pricing formulas that patients cannot easily use to determine their costs.

Missouri lawmakers deserve credit for taking another step toward greater healthcare price transparency, but there is still a long way to go. Going into next year’s legislative session, policymakers should consider establishing the state’s own requirements and enforcement mechanisms rather than relying entirely on Washington to determine if hospitals should face consequences.

Regulation Accounts for a Quarter of a New Home’s Price

A recent story in The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) reminds me that the cost of regulation is higher than you think. Especially with housing. And while Missouri is not the worst offender—our housing prices are relatively low—we are not spared the costs of government policy.

In 2024 I pointed out that the new energy codes adopted by Kansas City all but brought new housing projects to a standstill. Kansas City wasn’t alone. The Journal noted in its recent story: “new building codes, particularly around energy efficiency and fire suppression, have forced builders to construct more complex and expensive homes.” Kansas City eventually reversed itself, but the point remains: Adding rules and regulations drives up costs.

A study published by the National Association of Home Builders and referenced in the Journal piece estimates “regulations imposed by government at all levels account for 26.4% of the final price of a new single-family home built for sale—up almost three percentage points from the percentage reported in the 2021 study.”

What does that mean in Missouri? The U.S. Census indicates the average sales price of new homes sold in the Midwest region was $430,400 in Q1 2026—26.4% of which is $113,626. The Kansas City Regional Association of Realtors reports a September 2026 new-construction median of $532,500 and an average of $635,913. If the regulatory burden in Kansas City matches the national average, the costs of regulation for each would be $140,580 and $167,881, respectively.

These rules and regulations often have nothing to do with health or safety, such as minimum lot sizes, setbacks and myriad approvals. They drive up costs and make affordable housing almost impossible to build. Missouri lawmakers have noticed.

When it comes to housing regulations, Missouri and Kansas are just two of a handful of states with no statewide housing code, leaving municipalities to regulate on their own. But the recent spate of city regulations led the legislature to consider halting some municipal rules. In 2026, House Bill (HB) 2384 would have stopped cities from imposing energy codes more strict than the 2009 standards, required local governments to approve building permits within 30 days, and legalized single stair apartments. The bill died in the Senate.

Another effort, represented by Senate Bill (SB) 1431 and HB 3466, would have created a single statewide building code, overseen by a new state commission whose approval cities would need before amending it. Both bills died in committee. But having the state set the standard is no guarantee of better outcomes. A single code written in Jefferson City can be just as costly as dozens written at city halls.

What the legislature did pass was more subsidies. In July, Gov. Mike Kehoe signed HB 3231. The bill creates Missouri Innovation Zones, where developers can get property tax abatements, tax-increment financing, and a new tax credit for converting offices to housing. How much help a project gets depends on a 100-point scorecard that weighs housing creation, affordability, historic preservation, and other factors. That’s one of the troubles with subsidies—politicians can’t resist attaching more rules to them. The result is a perpetual red-tape machine, churning out new policies and higher prices rather than new homes.

Missouri has been spared a lot of the awful land regulations that have driven up housing costs elsewhere. We should be grateful for that, but not complacent. Of this year’s proposals, HB 2384 came closest to the right answer: not moving regulatory power from city hall to Jefferson City, but limiting how much any level of government can add to the cost of a home. The question isn’t who gets to regulate—it’s how to regulate less.

We Finally Get a Peek at MOScholars

Missouri’s first formal evaluation of student performance in the MOScholars tax-credit scholarship program has arrived, revealing strong student success alongside clear administrative growing pains. As reported by the Missouri Independent, an independent analysis conducted by Saint Louis University’s PRiME Center found that scholarship recipients scored near the national median (45th to 47th percentile) in reading and math. That’s impressive given that nearly 40 percent of scholarship recipients have specialized learning plans (IEPs), and the rest come from lower-income households.

However, the report also highlighted significant data collection hurdles. Researchers noted that disjointed reporting, unstandardized test formats, and missing family income data from several of the educational assistance organizations (EAOs) that award the scholarships hindered a comprehensive analysis. In response, critics in the state legislature have questioned the state treasurer’s oversight, while program administrators point out that new software partnerships and longitudinal tracking systems have since been established to standardize future reporting.

Creating an entirely new scholarship infrastructure outside traditional district channels inevitably involves operational hurdles. But measuring outcomes is vital and transparent academic tracking must continue to improve in order to protect the integrity of the program. The challenge is finding a balance between reporting compliance without imposing heavy-handed bureaucratic mandates that discourage private schools from participating.

The PRiME Center’s report proves that MOScholars is delivering real educational hope to high-need children. By fixing administrative reporting gaps while preserving provider flexibility, Missouri can ensure that parent-directed choice remains both accessible and sustainable.

Support Us

The work of the Show-Me Institute would not be possible without the generous support of people who are inspired by the vision of liberty and free enterprise. We hope you will join our efforts and become a Show-Me Institute sponsor.

Donate
Man on Horse Charging