Hospitals may be getting better at following federal price transparency rules, but are patients getting any closer to knowing what their care will cost? A new report suggests there’s still a significant gap between complying with the rules and providing prices patients can actually use.
PatientRightsAdvocate.org (PRA) reviewed 2,000 hospitals and found that 49.4% complied with federal transparency requirements, up from just 21.1% in its previous report. That’s substantial progress, but
PRA found that only 18% of hospitals posted what it calls “dollar-and-cents prices,” meaning an actual amount rather than a percentage or formula, for at least half of the items and services in their pricing files. Just 10% of hospitals were both fully compliant with federal requirements and met PRA’s standard for sufficient dollar-and-cents prices.
How can a hospital comply without posting an actual price? Federal rules allow hospitals to use percentages or formulas when a negotiated price cannot be expressed as a dollar amount in advance. PRA gives the example of a hospital that listed the negotiated price for an uncomplicated childbirth as 44.4% of its total billed charges. Although the file included historical payment amounts, the patient still could not determine what the birth would cost without knowing what charges would be included in the total.
The problem isn’t limited to hospitals outside Missouri. None of the eight Missouri SSM Health hospitals reviewed by PRA met its standard for sufficient dollar-and-cents pricing. Six were specifically cited because their formulas did not provide enough information for patients to determine an actual price.
Fortunately, the federal government has already taken steps to address these shortcomings. Updated requirements took effect in January, with enforcement beginning in April, requiring hospitals that use percentages or formulas to also report historical payment amounts in dollars. While those figures provide patients with more useful information, they still may not reveal what a particular service will cost. Because PRA reviewed hospital pricing files shortly after enforcement began, its findings do not tell us how hospitals have responded since then.
As I recently wrote, Missouri also enacted a new law restricting debt collection by hospitals that materially violate federal price transparency requirements. However, the law depends on federal action; the federal government can either levy a financial penalty or give official notification that a hospital failed to correct material deficiencies. None of the eight SSM hospitals appear on the federal penalty list, although that alone does not establish whether Missouri’s restrictions would apply.
The progress documented in PRA’s report is encouraging, but there is still a long way to go. Hospitals should provide prices patients can understand and compare before receiving care, and those that fail to meet federal requirements should face meaningful consequences. After nearly six years of federal price transparency requirements, patients shouldn’t still have to guess what their care will cost.
