• Publications
    • Essay
    • Case Study
    • Policy Study
    • Report
    • Testimony
    • Other
    • Newsletter
  • Blog
    • Daily Blog
    • Podcasts and Radio
    • Video
    • Infographics
    • Commentary / Op-Eds
    • Events
  • Events
  • Donate
  • About
    • Our Team
    • Show-Me Institute Board of Directors
    • Fellows and Scholars
    • Our Authors
    • Jobs
  • Contact
  • Explore Topics
    • Education
      • Accountability
      • Education Finance
      • Performance
      • School Choice
    • Health Care
      • Free-Market Reform
      • Medicaid
    • Corporate Welfare
      • Special Taxing Districts
      • Subsidies
      • Tax Credits
    • Labor
      • Government Unions
      • Public Pensions
    • State and Local Government
      • Budget and Spending
      • Courts
      • Criminal Justice
      • Municipal Policy
      • Property Rights
      • Transparency
      • Transportation
    • Economy
      • Business Climate
      • Energy
      • Minimum Wage
      • Privatization
      • Regulation
      • Taxes
      • Welfare
      • Workforce
Show Me InstituteShow Me Institute
Show Me InstituteShow Me Institute
Support the Show-Me Institute
  • Publications
    • Essay
    • Case Study
    • Policy Study
    • Report
    • Testimony
    • Other
    • Newsletter
  • Blog
    • Daily Blog
    • Podcasts and Radio
    • Video
    • Infographics
    • Commentary / Op-Eds
    • Events
  • Events
  • Donate
  • About
    • Our Team
    • Show-Me Institute Board of Directors
    • Fellows and Scholars
    • Our Authors
    • Jobs
  • Contact
  • Explore Topics
    • Education
      • Accountability
      • Education Finance
      • Performance
      • School Choice
    • Health Care
      • Free-Market Reform
      • Medicaid
    • Corporate Welfare
      • Special Taxing Districts
      • Subsidies
      • Tax Credits
    • Labor
      • Government Unions
      • Public Pensions
    • State and Local Government
      • Budget and Spending
      • Courts
      • Criminal Justice
      • Municipal Policy
      • Property Rights
      • Transparency
      • Transportation
    • Economy
      • Business Climate
      • Energy
      • Minimum Wage
      • Privatization
      • Regulation
      • Taxes
      • Welfare
      • Workforce
Education

Do Teacher Unions Matter?

By Audrey Spalding on Oct 28, 2009

A 2009 study in the October issue of the Journal of Labor Economics finds that teacher unions have no effect on teacher pay.

Shocking! As the author, Michael Lovenheim of Stanford University, notes, these results aren’t expected. Unions negotiate for better work conditions and salary increases, so it’s a general assumption that school district unionization would increase teacher pay. Previous studies have shown unionization to increase teacher pay by as much as 12 percent. A paper by Caroline Hoxby, seen here at the Show-Me Institute talking about the effects of collective bargaining, found that majority teacher union membership results in a 5-percent pay boost for teachers (study available here).

Looking at the source of Lovenheim’s data, I wonder whether his findings are attributable to a lack of available details. He calculated monthly teacher pay by dividing a district’s monthly full-time instructional payroll by the number of full-time instructional staff. That pool includes not only teachers, he writes in the study’s appendix, but also educational support staff, school-level administrators, principals, and guidance counselors.

The things I saw while attending teacher-administration contract negotiations at the Lindbergh School District in Saint Louis lead me to believe that educational support staff, school-level administrators, principals, and guidance counselors don’t necessarily benefit from teacher union negotiations, even if the union purports to represent them. In fact, in the Lindbergh case, they lost out slightly. (Administrators and the teacher union ended up agreeing that counselors and librarians should contribute to the “substitute pool” when absent from school, even though substitutes aren’t hired when either counselors or librarians are absent.)

The average pay Lovenheim calculated could be obscuring teacher gains because of the varying salary trends among non-teacher staff. For an example of this in action, see the Miami-Dade School District. After 16 months of negotiations, the district awarded its teachers an average 1.8-percent raise, while “reducing the number of days support staff will work from 260 to 250.” For the unindoctrinated, school districts generally can’t cut pay; instead, they cut days.

Another issue with analyzing the effects of unionization on teacher compensation is that non-salary benefits, such as health, life, and vision insurance, as well as working conditions, are difficult information to find, and can be very hard to quantify. The lack of availability, Lovenheim writes, forced him to leave those measures of compensation out of his study. Non-salary benefits are not inconsequential, and can add up to thousands of dollars more in compensation. If unionization helps teachers negotiate for more non-salary benefits, that could amount to a large positive effect left unaccounted.

I’m not quite sure whether the following is a non-salary or a salary benefit. In any case, it’s my favorite teacher union contract provision. From the Mehlville School District’s 2009–2010 agreement with its teacher union:

Any savings exceeding $70,000 between now and August 1 resulting from teacher staff changes will be added to the base salary.

That surely is evidence of teacher union negotiating power, especially during a recession when school districts across the state are looking at ways to make cuts.

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Email
  • Print
About the author

Audrey Spalding

More about this author >
    Footer Logo
    Support the Show-Me-Institute
    Showmeinstitute.org is brought to you by Show-Me Institute and Show-Me Opportunity.
    • Publications
    • Blog
    • Events
    • Donate
    • About
    • Contact

    Reprint permission for Show-Me Institute publications and commentaries is hereby granted, provided that proper credit is given to the author. We request, but do not require, that those who reprint our material notify us of publication for our records: [email protected]

    Mission Statement
    Advancing liberty with responsibility by promoting market solutions for Missouri public policy.

    © Copyright 2023 All Rights Reserved