Developer Should Bear Risk of Failure

I was pleased to see that the Post-Dispatch ran a letter to the editor today that I wrote in response to its recent editorial calling for St. Louis officials to renew efforts to subsidize the NorthSide redevelopment plan. This is the text of the letter:

Developer Should Bear Risk of Failure

In responding to Judge Robert Dierker’s ruling that St. Louis officials lacked authority to offer hundreds of millions of dollars to subsidize the NorthSide redevelopment plan, the editorial board, in the editorial “Celebrating Decline” (July 12), implies that the plan can proceed only if the city provides the anticipated subsidies. The developer’s own estimates indicate a belief that he will realize a profit of at least $251 million even without those subsidies.

Nothing in the ruling prevents the developer from pursuing his quixotic vision or from enjoying any profits that might result from its success; rather, it requires that, like all other entrepreneurs, the developer must personally bear the risks of failure instead of pushing them onto the taxpaying public.

Dave Roland — St. Louis

Policy Analyst, Show-Me Institute